Re:Python data tools just keep getting better
by ryporter on Monday March 25, 2013 @06:58AM
(#5436403)
In defense of Wes, the book does do a good job of introducing you to IPython and NumPy. I had mainly used Python as a generic scripting language prior to reading much of this book, mainly writing vanilla scripts in emacs. Afterwards (and with the help of online pandas docs), I felt like I was fairly productive at analyzing some new data that had been thrown my way.
I can definitely see why some think that the title is misleading. The book clearly does not aim to survey the field of data analysis in Python. However, it does teach you everything you need to know to start doing data analysis in Python using one particular (good) tool chain.
Re:Python data tools just keep getting better
by piqufoh on Monday March 25, 2013 @06:22AM
(#5436315)
Wes, there needs to be a great book about Pandas as it's an amazing tool, and you've written it. But Data Analysis is a HUGE subject and passively implying that it can only be tackled with Pandas is misleading. My post was intended to be a snark at O'Reilly's general failing quality - I'm sorry if I put your nose out of joint.
Re:Python data tools just keep getting better
by darkxanthos on Monday March 25, 2013 @07:58AM
(#5436526)
I do data analysis and pandas is a huge part of that. He can't usefully write about the whole universe of data analysis. The part he wrote about is definitely quite relevant.
Re:Python data tools just keep getting better
by nullsub on Monday March 25, 2013 @08:25AM
(#5436605)
Have to agree, piqufoh's comment is asinine. Pandas is the first time I've even considered moving work done in R to a new all-python workflow. Exhaustive coverage by some imaginary, disinterested third party would still be forced to settle on pandas as the focus, because it literally is the only game in town.
As to the merits, per se, of having some third party write the book: I'm doubtful. I followed wesm's development through blog posts, twitter updates, etc. Writing pandas forced him to consider a lot aspects of dealing with data in python, both deep and practical. In the process, I'm confident he became one of the foremost experts in not only his own software but in the current state of Data Analysis in Python. Who better to write this book?
The sales numbers already show that the book was timely and relevant to a huge (> 10,000 so far) number of people.