News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by luu on Sunday March 24, 2013 @11:38AM (#5432331)
I wonder how long it will be before other companies start doing this.

At his confirmation hearing, when Alan Greenspan was asked why Townsend-Greenspan employed so many women (> 50%, compared to about 5% in finance at the time), he replied that since he valued women as much as men, but other firms didn't, he could get more work for the same amount money by hiring women. Now, of course, the difference has mostly been arbitraged away, but it took decades to get to this point.

At the time, people gave many reasons sexism couldn't possibly exist in finance; naturally, more men went into finance because women just didn't like finance, and more men had senior positions because simply didn't want senior positions, and so on and so forth (oddly enough, those same reasons are given today, in discussions of sexism in CS and engineering).

In 1987, Townsend-Greenspan shut down, after thirty successful years, because Greenspan became chairman of the Fed. Now, twenty-six years later, the gender gap among MBAs is much smaller than it used to be, but it hasn't disappeared. I hope it doesn't take fifty-six years from the founding of Etsy for someone to be able to make a comment like this about programmers.

I'm afraid it might be a while, though. In discussions about the topic here on HN, the top comment is often something along the lines of how there obviously isn't any sexism in the field, or if there is any, it's rare, and certainly not a systematic problem, and how it's simply impossible that the highly skewed male:female ratio in the field is due to sexism. That's usually followed by a paragraph on how any attempts to address the issue are an insidious cause of reverse sexism.

The top comment in the previous thread on this topic was a comment about how everything Etsy is doing applies equally to all people, not just women, despite a large body of research indicating that, on average, women are treated differently in the workplace [1], and how some simple changes can neutralize many serious problems [2].

[1] Perhaps someone else can supply a reference to a well-known study that I can't seem to look up. When men react with anger, or act authoritatively, that's seen neutrally or positively, but when women do the same, it's seen negatively.

[2] http://papers.nber.org/papers/w18511

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by jerrya on Sunday March 24, 2013 @12:05PM (#5432427)
The article doesn't describe sexism, the article describes scarcity and demand:

In Silicon Valley today it's not possible to hire more women simply by recruiting them. Good engineers today have their pick of jobs, and good female engineers are being stalked like the last antelope on the African veldt.

Etsy's solution doesn't seem to be to stop sexism, Etsy's solution appears to be train more engineers, take a risk on junior women engineers out of Hacker School, and let their risk taking and boots on the ground approach serve as a signal to senior women engineers.

None of this is evidence of sexism in CS and engineering, it was a winning strategy to defeat scarcity.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by subsystem on Sunday March 24, 2013 @01:04PM (#5432645)
The argument is that sexism is what creates the scarcity in the first place. So by creating an environment where sexism is less of a factor you attract more women.
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by Tichy on Sunday March 24, 2013 @04:04PM (#5433350)
There is nothing in that experiment supporting that theory, though. So why push it anyway? How does people flocking to free education prove anything?
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by subsystem on Sunday March 24, 2013 @04:50PM (#5433508)
If you can't see my point and want me to elaborate, ask like a normal civilized person and I might.
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by Tichy on Sunday March 24, 2013 @04:54PM (#5433532)
What didn't you like about the way I asked?
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by subsystem on Sunday March 24, 2013 @05:54PM (#5433889)
You're asking a rhetorical question that insults my character by implying that I would fabricate a theory and then "push it" although I knew it was false. I'm fine with not being right or people having a different opinion, but don't insult me in the process.

Your other question doesn't make sense since it's factually incorrect (hackers school was free before) and puts weight on only one factor. The incentive Etsy made for women to join hacker school was of course offsetting some other factors. I'm saying that sexism or something devolved from sexism is one of those other factors.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by Tichy on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:52PM (#5434428)
I didn't say you fabricated it, just that it doesn't follow from the story. That there was something to offset also doesn't imply sexism was in the mix of things to offset.
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by subsystem on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:59PM (#5434661)
See, you didn't actually say story, you said experiment. I wouldn't base my theories on a single story. Instead I've been following this experiment for a year, during which many of the people involved seem to think that sexism actually is one of the factors.

Hacker school amended their policy with "no subtle sexism", the CTO of Etsy said that it was harder to hire great women because they tend to have a history of bad experience and one of the attendees, which was later hired by Etsy, specifically pointed out sexism as a problem within the tech community.

This of course also make me think that sexism or, like I said, something devolved from sexism actually is a factor for women. It was at least definitely part of the experiment.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4LExVkv4Pw http://firstround.com/article/How-Etsy-Grew-their-Number-of-... http://marthakelly.github.com/blog/2013/03/10/an-open-letter...

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by Tichy on Monday March 25, 2013 @08:39AM (#5436642)
The number of people believing something is not a good indicator for it being true oe not. Example: billions of people have contradictory religious beliefs.
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by subsystem on Monday March 25, 2013 @05:25PM (#5439805)
The number of independent people believing something combined with their authenticity, trustworthiness, or competency is basic information valuation[0]. Religious beliefs fall not on how many people believe them, but because they all originate from either untrustworthy or distant sources. Otherwise the laws of physics would be false, since many people also believe them.

In any case that doesn't matter since what you actually said that sexism wasn't one of the factors and I've shown that is was. We haven't even begun talking about how large a factor it was since you haven't been providing any real perspective on the matter. At this point I seriously doubt your ability to provide any value in this conversation and are therefor going to stop participating in it.

[0] https://www.fas.org/irp/doddir/army/fm2-22-3.pdf

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by Tichy on Monday March 25, 2013 @06:22PM (#5440092)
You've shown that the organizers thought that sexism was a factor, which isn't the same thing. But you are right, since we fundamentally disagree about the rules of logic, further discussion is pointless. (example: I said truth doesn't follow from many people believing in something, you interpret it as 'everything many people believe is false'. Very basic logic mistake)
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by enraged_camel on Sunday March 24, 2013 @02:57PM (#5433071)
Yep, exactly. By funding this training program Etsy signaled that they value women as much as they value men. As a result, a ton of women applied to the program and many of those ended up getting hired.
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by Tichy on Sunday March 24, 2013 @04:02PM (#5433343)
Or maybe it's just thast they paid for their education. Getting something for free could attract a lot of people.

I also would like an update on the results in 5 years.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by usaar333 on Sunday March 24, 2013 @01:03PM (#5432637)
Of course, you can find plenty of sexism in both finance and engineering. And I'm sure it discourages some women from entering.

But it is important to note there are plenty of industries today with high female representation, such as law and medicine, that in the recent past were bastions of male dominance. A female relative of mine went through law school in the 1950s and can tell tales of male chauvinism more extreme than you'd find anywhere today in tech or finance. But somehow, women went to law school more and more, and today represent ~50% of law classes. Something must be different about these fields, but I'm not sure what.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by vacri on Sunday March 24, 2013 @05:14PM (#5433634)
Probably not the reason, but it's worth noting that law and medicine historically had women in some roles, albeit subservient. Typically your court reporters were female, and of course nurses were pretty much all female. There weren't any roles in ye olde engineering where it was typical to see a woman at all.

Edit: probably more telling is that both law and medicine are heavily involved in a sense of social responsibility, something that women are traditionally socialised for. Engineering not so much.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by duggan on Sunday March 24, 2013 @01:20PM (#5432704)
Theory: the fields you mention, law and medicine, (historically and still) convey a higher social status on the member. There's also a relatively well trodden path through apprenticeship, successful practitioner, and eventual transition into other stable/respectable paths (politics, judiciary, hospital administration) as your career winds down.

Software engineering doesn't have that (yet?)

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by philwelch on Sunday March 24, 2013 @02:03PM (#5432861)
People haven't aspired to become software engineers for generations. Only the past few years. In 1990, no one told their daughters that they could be software engineers. They told their daughters they could be lawyers and doctors, or maybe Senators, or business executives. Software engineering? Who wanted to do that?
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by duggan on Sunday March 24, 2013 @03:53PM (#5433299)
Out of 150 students that graduated my year of high school (2003), an all boys school, I was the only one who chose to follow a computing career.

All my friends, even those with a similar (or more advanced) aptitude and interest in computers, chose different paths. Chemistry. Theoretical Physics. History. Politics. Economics.

Nobody wanted to be doing computing professionally. Men were/are afforded to be outcasts or underdogs, socially; there's some romanticism to it. I'm not sure the same has applied for women, but maybe that's changing.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by reeses on Sunday March 24, 2013 @01:59PM (#5432843)
Supportive parents, significant others, and friends? The first wave of militant[1] feminists repeatedly reinforced that women were the equivalent of men in many ways and better in some[2]. Women today (under 40 or 50 years old) have had the benefit of hearing the same "you can do anything" message that parents have told their sons. Girls and women are supported socially when their MBA (which was the first professional non-library sciences, teaching, etc. that took off), JD, and MD. Mothers and Fathers are as proud of their daughters being excellent as they are of their sons.

Sure, there are religious, geographical, and socio-economic holdouts, but I think that this is one of the three big factors.

The second is that men tend to drop out to get jobs. If you can make $150k out of school with a BS EECS, why go to law or med school? Again, using my wife and her circle of female attorneys as examples, women seem to be more interested in personal satisfaction and are willing to pay a price for it, whether it's working in a rough environment (Kabul, Kosovo, Department of Homeland Security) or postponing that satisfaction by spending more time in school.

The third is that med and law school are great careers with a lot of opportunities for women who want to have children. Sure, there's partner track that will not necessarily be an option, but again, they don't always have the same "must be alpha" drive that men do. They can take a year off, maybe start back in a step behind, maybe work part time, but know that they can do the job they like, with variety in cases, until they decide to retire.

Of course, there are a bunch of contributory factors that I didn't cover and don't know how universal they are, but on the "sexist" side, it's still more acceptable for a woman to take time off and be supported by her husband than the other way around. You have exceptions, like ESR, so I don't think it's as influential.

Finally, they still put up with a lot of sexism, but they know it's wrong and that it is not a reflection on them, but on the morons trying to put them down. Not that it doesn't hurt, but sometimes hurt is a good motivator to succeed in spite of others.

[1] For want of a better word. [2] Just as I am better at feats of strength than my wife, who works out 1-2x/daily, but she is better at doing the type of research necessary to be one of the best litigators most attorneys have seen.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by walshemj on Sunday March 24, 2013 @05:31PM (#5433764)
Law and Medicine both get more pay and have higher social status and have less ageism :-)

And if you SE is hard try being a woman in Civil engineering - a place I worked at (an Arab Civil engineers) had to arrange a swap with an Italian Consulting engineers. All our work was in the middle east so she was unable to get the required boots on the ground experience on our projects to progress to chartered status.

Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by Tichy on Sunday March 24, 2013 @02:04PM (#5432864)
There are glamorous TV shows about law and medicine. None I am aware of for programming.
Re:How Etsy Attracted 500% More Female Engineers by wglb on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:50PM (#5434622)
I have a friend who has been doing this at a significant business ($70m/yr) in a very high technology company for over 20 years. When I asked "what if no women apply?" Her answer was "you aren't looking hard enough."