News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unfit for work by mdasen on Friday March 22, 2013 @06:38PM (#5426225)
I appreciate your post and your pain. However, one thing that I will point out is that one data point is not something one can draw conclusions from. A friend of mine's father (Ph.D. and desk job) died in his early 50s too.

Looking at data, it seems that the sedentary-jobbed have a life expectancy of 79.3 while the manual workers have a life expectancy of 75 years. So, there is a difference of 4.3 years (males, UK 2002-2005). It should also be noted that life expectancy for the manual group has gone up about 7 years since 1972-1976 (the sedentary saw a similar 7 year increase).

Governments aren't looking to increase the retirement age to dangle some carrot in front of people they consider too stupid to know better. If life expectancy is going up by 7 years, that means that a pension needs to provide income for more years. That means higher taxes, raising the retirement age, or putting more onus on the individual to save for retirement. There's a genuine question: where would the money come from to give someone a retirement at 50? To provide the average 50 year old male a $50,000 salary for the rest of their life costs over $1M - and that isn't $50,000 adjusted for inflation. What does that come out to per year? Assuming the kind of conservative planning that the government does, over $20,000 pear year. Essentially, we would need a tax of 40% for people to be able to retire at 50 and replace their income for life. Now, maybe 75% income replacement is ok and a 33% tax would do it. But then you have to think about providing inflation adjustments and healthcare for that period and it's just not good. Health costs are rising substantially faster than inflation. Should we lock people into the standard of care at the year of their retirement with newer, more expensive treatments unavailable to them?

There's just a big money issue when it comes to retirement age that's hard to ignore. Ideally, none of us would ever have to work. Unfortunately, that isn't our reality. Not to become too weird, but it's really tragic when you think about it. We're these biological beings trying to strive against what would happen to us if we stopped working to survive. And we've created some awesomeness to make our existence a lot better (medicine, for instance), but it's a thin veil over the harshness of what happens to us in the absence of working to survive. To come back down to earth, it's really crappy that we can't have the same retirement age that we used to have. However, I'm not sure how to go about talking about retirement ages without talking about the money we need to support it. Maybe it's time we raised social security taxes realizing that we don't care as much about iPhones as we do about our retirement. Ultimately, it isn't about governments trying to hurt people, but governments not having the money to offer it.

It should also be noted that a lot of these jobs pay better than similarly skilled jobs that are more sedentary. Construction salaries average $44,630. Office and administrative work averages $34,120. Sales $37,520. Personal Care $24,620. Part of the higher salary might be because of the nature of the work you speak of. The additional money per year could go toward providing an earlier retirement via individual means. I know that most people won't save and that's why I like social security. Maybe we should have a lower retirement age for certain professions along with higher social security and medicare taxes on jobs in those professions.

--

I can't imagine how hard it is to lose a parent so young. I'm sorry.

Re:Unfit for work by naa42 on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:23AM (#5427354)
> Where would the money come from to give someone a retirement at 50?

Well, it looks completely different if we take out the money from this situation.

Consider this: we have big unemployment, a lot of part-time workers, a lot of people not working because of disabilities, there are also millions of college and university students who are obviously not working full time. But the economy keeps going, it has no shortage of workforce, number of workplaces is limited and less than total number of people.

Then you propose to increase retirement age.

The number of workers will increase, but the number of workplaces is the same. Wages are decreasing, tax revenue is decreasing and we again have no money to pay welfare, pensions etc. So we don't need more workforce.

Redundant workers rely on disability pensions, unemployment payments, food stamps etc. All these welfare programs have obvious deficiencies, but we need to feed the people anyway. If these people were working it would be much better. But there is simple way to increase number of working people without extra resources.

We just need to limit working hours. And it is possible, because it was possible to introduce 40 hour work week. Now cut it to 35, and you get 12% increase of number of working people and unemployment completely disappears.

Re:Unfit for work by sheefrex on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:52AM (#5427510)
That train of thought is known as the lump of labour fallacy.

What you propose would reduce output; if it was optimal for firms to hire the unemployed, in place of those already employed, then they would do so - unless they are prevented from doing so by labour legislation, which doesn't seem to be the case the U.S.

That the unemployed are not hired might make sense when there are costs to hiring and training a new worker, which don't exist for a worker already in place. On an aggregate level, this policy would increase the cost of labour, and consequently reduce its demand, so less overall would be employed (though the rate of employment would probably stay about constant because you reduced the denominator by reducing the labour force).

Probably a better explanation here: http://www.economist.com/economics-a-to-z/l#node-21529454

Re:Unfit for work by readme on Saturday March 23, 2013 @05:57AM (#5427689)
That's a great point, but it's only a definition. Being a definition in an economics text (in this case, just a website) doesn't make it automatically correct. It needs to be proven by research.
Re:Unfit for work by eli_gottlieb on Saturday March 23, 2013 @10:27AM (#5428234)
"In theory, theory and practice are identical. In practice, they're not."

A fair portion of the Western world's underemployment and unemployment problem derives directly from the overemployment of those who have the jobs. As people keep putting it, "Whatever happened to the 40-hour workweek?"

For example, among those sedentary professionals who can keep working for decades upon decades, most in the United States are classified as Fair Labor Standards Act exempt, and are therefore often made to work overtime. Health insurance is a fixed cost that needs to be driven down both through socializing medicine and, preferably, through requiring per-hour National Insurance taxes, but only the latter action would actually change the fact that firms find it cheaper to hire two professionals working 60 hours/week each than to hire three professionals for normal 40-hour workweeks.

And, here's the trick, neither of those two professionals actually receives overtime pay. The company is literally getting a 1/3 boost to their productivity-per-employee solely by using a legal loophole to not pay for all hours worked. This is not the lump-of-labor fallacy, it's straightforward exploitation.

To paraphrase many Hacker News-targeted blogposts, "Fuck companies, pay workers."

Re:Unfit for work by raintrees on Sunday March 24, 2013 @01:54AM (#5431289)
Thanks, I like the quote re: theory and practice and will swipe it for my own re-use...

Attribution?

Re:Unfit for work by dragonwriter on Sunday March 24, 2013 @12:26PM (#5432505)
> What you propose would reduce output; if it was optimal for firms to hire the unemployed, in place of those already employed, then they would do so - unless they are prevented from doing so by labour legislation, which doesn't seem to be the case the U.S.

Payroll taxes definitely do work in that way (not as an outright barrier, but by acting as a market distortion which encourages investing in expanding production through expanding capital rather than doing so by expanding employment rolls when, before considering payroll tax costs, it would be equally or more efficient to expand production by expanding employment.)

Re:Unfit for work by useful on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:38AM (#5427490)
Doesn't the Obama care insurance penalty basically do this? Companies are forced to either spend $10000 per employee like they do do now to give them coverage or pay a $2000 fine to the government. The beauty of this is that part time workers are exempt from the fine so most companies will just hire 25% more people and make everyone only work 30 hours.

Unemployment is basically solved in 2014. Under employment on the other hand...

Re:Unfit for work by petercooper on Saturday March 23, 2013 @05:11AM (#5427630)
Re:Unfit for work by martinced on Saturday March 23, 2013 @11:14AM (#5428428)
Exactly. They tried that in France at a moment where everybody was euphoric: the two germanies had recently been re-unified and GDPs of nearly everybody were growing like crazy.

Instead of France trying to reimburse its own public state debt they decided to move to 35 hours / week.

We can see the results now: Germany's economy is one of the best in the eurozone, they managed to stay at "only" 80% of public debt and are enjoying a modest GDP growth. Meanwhile France reached 100% public debt and is dangerously close to a disaster (youth unemployment is rising, the private sector isn't motivated anymore, austerity will need to kick in or France won't be able to re-finance itself on the markets).

The loss of competitivity of France is directly attributed to moving to 35 hours / week and is going to be the main reason why France is going to lose its status as the world's fifth biggest power. By 2017 Brazil's going to be in front of France. Heck, if Holland and the socialist gets re-elected there's a far from zero probability that France won't be part of the G8 anymore by 2022!

That is very concerning but, sadly, there's nothing else to hope from socialists who are spreading hatred of the entrepreneurial spirit and hatred of those who succeeded, in the name of the nanny state spraying loyal socialist voters with money inflating their sense of entitlement.

Re:Unfit for work by shubb on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:57PM (#5429009)
And yet, having a 35 hour work week for 30 years is a huge achievement in itself. That's a billion hours not worked.

International economics is too complex to pin France's woes on one single factor, especially when they have a lower debt to GDP than the US which is famous for it's long working hours.

There is a lot wrong in the French economy. There is a lot uniquely wrong with every economy. I'd argue that as the huge populations of BRIC countries use modern productivity tools like automation to increase per capita GDP, it would be bizarre for France to hope to stay in the G8. And that's a win for everyone.

Re:Unfit for work by bjourne on Saturday March 23, 2013 @04:22AM (#5427591)
You're thinking of "money" as a resource that can be depleted like a forest or an iron mine. But that's not true, the amount of money is constant -- it just changes hands a lot. First graph shows that everyone could retire comfortably at age 50:

http://www.data360.org/dsg.aspx?Data_Set_Group_Id=231

GNP (red line) tripled since 1970. That means, on average, every worker got three times more efficient. So why on earth do we have to talk about a lack of money when society's wealth has increased so fast?

http://current.com/shows/the-war-room/blog/what-you-need-to-...

Money is about power and is a zero sum game. If someone increases their share of the pie, then someone else necessarily loses out.

Re:Unfit for work by lazyjones on Saturday March 23, 2013 @06:50AM (#5427737)
> But that's not true, the amount of money is constant -- it just changes hands a lot.

No it's not: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_supply#United_States

> GNP (red line) tripled since 1970 [...] So why on earth do we have to talk about a lack of money when society's wealth has increased so fast? [... Link to income gap ... ]

It's less of a problem of income distribution than one of wealth distribution. The key issue is that people with lower incomes accumulate assets that cost them money (house, car, TV...) while those with higher income collect stocks, bonds, rentable real estate property, all of which generate more wealth.

Re:Unfit for work by bjourne on Saturday March 23, 2013 @10:05AM (#5428147)
>> But that's not true, the amount of money is constant -- it just changes hands a lot. > No it's not: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_supply#United_States

Right. Governments print money all the time, but the total value of all the money remains constant, thanks to inflation. It's just a measure of how much power someone has in a society compared to everyone else.

> It's less of a problem of income distribution than one of wealth distribution. The key issue is that people with lower incomes accumulate assets that cost them money (house, car, TV...) while those with higher income collect stocks, bonds, rentable real estate property, all of which generate more wealth.

That's not given by God. Stocks didn't use to be money making machines and there is nothing that says they have to be. Stocks have been doing amazingly well since about 1980's because during the same time period wages have gotten a smaller and smaller share of the gnp. The ugly truth of the stock market is that for every winner there is also a loser.

Re:Unfit for work by marcamillion on Sunday March 24, 2013 @09:54AM (#5432036)
>> Right. Governments print money all the time, but the total value of all the money remains constant, thanks to inflation. It's just a measure of how much power someone has in a society compared to everyone else.

Inflation, by it's definition, is caused because more money is chasing the same goods & services...which drives the prices up. That's why loose monetary policy (i.e. the Fed printing money) often comes with lots of "concerns about inflation".

Also...if money was indeed constant as you suggest, and it's just a power tool, then why have we seen 2 phenemona in the last 100 years.

1. The greatest number of people are moving out of absolute poverty, than at any other time in recorded history (hundreds of millions if not 1 Billion+ by now) - meaning, more people (as a % of the global population) are earning enough income to move themselves out of an abject poverty state, at a faster rate than at any other time in recent recorded history.

2. The greatest income gaps between the top 1% of the top 1% and the rest.

If the money supply were constant, both of those would be mutually exclusive. But they are not.

Anybody can create wealth, likewise anyone can destroy wealth. Money is just the physical/tradable manifestation of wealth. It's just a proxy. That's all. No conspiracy to see here.

Re:Unfit for work by precisioncoder on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @03:52AM (#5448300)
I think you misunderstood his argument. Assuming I understand correctly he was saying that if you have $100 in your society and 100 goods available for purchase, evenly each good is $1, if you have $200 and 100 goods each good is $2. Despite doubling your money it is still worth the same. Obviously it is more complex than that but I think that's the basic idea he was getting at. You can only increase the wealth of a country if you increase the amount of goods rather than the amount of money as money will more or less scale to goods. From what I understood he was referring to goods as wealth.
Re:Unfit for work by jonknee on Saturday March 23, 2013 @10:21AM (#5428207)
> The ugly truth of the stock market is that for every winner there is also a loser.

That's hardly the case. The only loser is someone who sell a stock for a loss (and even then considering dividends and the tax advantages it doesn't necessarily mean a net loss).

Re:Unfit for work by precisioncoder on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @03:57AM (#5448308)
If our economy has $100 we both receive a paycheck for half the remaining money and you buy a stock that gives you $1/year and I do not, assuming we spend the same you will automatically become richer each year until we are both paid a pittance while you sit on most of the money. I think that was the general idea.
Re:Unfit for work by stouset on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @02:15PM (#5451056)
Except, the reason the stock is giving $1/year, is because the economy is actually growing by $1/year.
Re:Unfit for work by precisioncoder on Friday March 29, 2013 @03:01AM (#5459616)
Assuming that is true inflation will still decrease the real value of the goods I purchase providing you with a greater share of the economy year after year. The general idea is that goods will increase at a higher rate than $1/year providing me with more wealth regardless of how rich you become. Unfortunately while a good idea in theory it hasn't really seemed to work in the US. The gap between the rich and the poor increased dramatically and minimum wage workers having trouble surviving.
Re:Unfit for work by Klinky on Saturday March 23, 2013 @08:02AM (#5427828)
So wealthy people do not bother with housing, transportation or entertainment, and instead put all their money into investments? I think it's more likely wealthy people had income sources that allowed them to invest, while still enjoying some level of comfort.
Re:Unfit for work by tankenmate on Saturday March 23, 2013 @08:22AM (#5427864)
I think it is reasonably clear from the GP that relative levels of investment was the gist; of course rich people live somewhere, moves about and try to keep themselves happy.
Re:Unfit for work by Klinky on Saturday March 23, 2013 @08:30AM (#5427878)
Then I don't see why it's important to state that those with lower incomes paying for housing, transportation or entertainment is the reason for their inability to become wealthy. Merely stating a difference in income causes the disparity is enough. Housing, transportation, communications, food and even entertainment are necessities.
Re:Unfit for work by jonknee on Saturday March 23, 2013 @10:23AM (#5428222)
No, it's just that wealthy people do not put the majority of their income into cost centers and instead put them into investments.
Re:Unfit for work by wildgift on Saturday March 23, 2013 @12:27PM (#5428683)
That's because they have more money. You have to pay for the necessities, and then you can save. If you're making near minimum wage, you won't be able to save much.

Also, those investments, like stocks and rental properties, transfer wealth from the poor to the rich, generally.

Re:Unfit for work by jonknee on Saturday March 23, 2013 @12:40PM (#5428745)
Sure, no one is disputing the fact that rich people have more money than poor people. For many reasons the rich get richer at the expense of the poor, the OP was noting one of the reasons.

Another is that the tax code incentivizes making your income through investments, something unattainable for people who aren't rich.

Re:Unfit for work by raintrees on Sunday March 24, 2013 @01:50AM (#5431285)
I would suggest it is not so much related to level of income, but rather knowledge of money management. The choice of buying more assets than liabilities is a basic, reliable (although frequently dull) way of acquiring wealth.

I am reminded of frequent stories of individuals with large incomes still being relatively poor - Doctors, Lawyers, etc. purchasing ever larger houses, ever more luxurious automobiles, etc. (all liabilities).

Or, as one individual who like to get peoples' attention puts it: "It's not how much money you make, but how much you keep."

Re:Unfit for work by alexakarpov on Saturday March 23, 2013 @11:14AM (#5428427)
> Money is about power and is a zero sum game. > If someone increases their share of the pie, > then someone else necessarily loses out.

Except this is plain wrong. I know a Wikipedia link may offend some people, but then again, calling economics a zero-sum game can, too: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero%E2%80%93sum_game#Economics

Re:Unfit for work by codeoclock on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:47AM (#5427400)
> Ideally, none of us would ever have to work. Unfortunately, that isn't our reality.

Yet! Seriously, lets just focus on building robots to do things like build roads and buildings, tend farms, drive vehicles, etc. etc. We could almost definitely pass human efficiency in the next 50 years, and nobody would ever have to do manual work again (although if that's something somebody likes doing they should totally have the option if that's what they want).

Also, I'm not convinced a job in construction is "similarly skilled" to office and admin work. But that's kind of beside the point, it's possible to earn a good living from either manual or sedentary work. Sure, the extremely high earners are exclusively sedentary workers (if they work in the traditional sense at all), but that speaks to the wider problem of wealth distribution, where the fabled top 1% have 20% of the countries total wealth.

Re:Unfit for work by translocation on Saturday March 23, 2013 @03:34AM (#5427551)
In the US, the top 1% own 35% of the country's total wealth.
Re:Unfit for work by shubb on Saturday March 23, 2013 @02:05PM (#5429039)
But I wonder - if they spent it, would it still have the same value?

Imagine one year, everyone spent all their income on stuff - earned and unearned. How much would an ipad cost? There is a limited capacity to raise ipad production - building new factories takes time. So the cost of an ipad would increase.

Right now, all that wealth is locked up in various markets, increasing the value of property and various past what is rational. If it suddenly came out to play, surely we'd see things people need to live increase more than the poorest can afford.

Is wealth that is never going to be spent really wealth?

Re:Unfit for work by pekk on Saturday March 23, 2013 @03:00PM (#5429283)
This argument is reduced to absurdity because it suggests that everyone will get things cheapest if one Scrooge McDuck accumulates all the wealth and simply sits on it.
Re:Unfit for work by whatshisface on Saturday March 23, 2013 @03:47PM (#5429472)
There's nothing absurd about deflation.

If you took 50% of all the money out of the world, the money that was left would be worth twice as much.

Re:Unfit for work by eli_gottlieb on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:48AM (#5431907)
That's exactly the argument that was had in the Western world starting with the '70s inflation "crisis", and this was indeed the conclusion people came to: radical inequality is an acceptable price to pay for low inflation. And now we're suffering the consequences of having an overly deflationary labor market.
Re:Unfit for work by Helianthus on Friday March 22, 2013 @08:11PM (#5426639)
>However, one thing that I will point out is that one data point is not something one can draw conclusions from.

Well, you missed the point entirely. He argued from a historical standpoint--in particular the involvement of the whole demographic in making the transformation of 1950s America to 1970s America--that you touch on with only one (largely irrelevant) statistical 'anecdote.'