There's no single good definitive source, but I'll link a few random ones I've seen point to cool stuff in the past:
There is also indiestatik ( http://indiestatik. com) which is entirely based around indie games.
IndieStatik's really nice - lots of in-depth stuff as opposed to rewritten press releases. (OK, they gave my game a positive review, so maybe I'm biased.)
http://indiegames.com/ is pretty good for learning about new games, but not great for reviews
It's surprising just how uninformative some game websites are. That includes websites of the game devs.