Previous life expectancy levels were based on poor public health levels and tended to be solved by improvements in public health. It is entirely reasonable to claim someone dying at fifty today is dying prematurely due being overworked.
See:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_expectancy#Life_expectancy...
"Life expectancy increases with age as the individual
survives the higher mortality rates associated with
childhood. For instance, the table above listed life
expectancy at birth in Medieval Britain at 30. A male
member of the English aristocracy at the same period
could expect to live, having survived until the age of
21
1200-1300 C.E.: 43 years (to age 64)
1300-1400 C.E.: 34 years (to age 55)
(due to the impact of the Black Death)
1400-1500 C.E.: 48 years (to age 69)
1500-1550 C.E.: 50 years (to age 71)."Interesting table though thank you
Its more than the type of work you do, that simply adds risk - some you see and some you don't. If anything it can be all the idle time shift workers have off work that kills them faster. Inactivity doesn't help the body age. I am quite sure a good number of people I work with will not live to a ripe old age and all they do is sit at a desk... and then go home and sit on a sofa or desk again
Physical labor can become debilitating when there is injury that is not allowed to heal completely or when there are excessive hours compounded by stress. Aside from that, it's probably very good for you.
Were this still the norm, then the focus would still be on working life health checkups and realising we cannot lift into our 70s. I think perhaps we are missing something there.
I suspect it might be worth linking retirement payouts to total calories burnt over a working life. Sitting at a desk might not be such a good career move :-)
Please again - I saw your point about your father as noteworthy and I wanted to recognise that - no offense or other comment meant