News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unfit for work by mkr-hn on Friday March 22, 2013 @04:35PM (#5425522)
The point of a basic income is to ensure everyone has the means to improve their standing, and keep from sliding into abject poverty. Any use of the funds that furthers that goal is legitimate. Social pressure can be exerted to limit frivolous uses, but it's easy for that to go too far and become counterproductive.

The worst that happens is someone has more than they need. And then what happens?

One of two things:

1: It sits in the bank, where it's lent out for investment

2: It's spent, possibly on something optional but still legitimately useful and non-frivolous, in which case it flows back out into the economy

I don't see a bad outcome. The vast majority of people want to have the self-esteem boost of fulfilling employment, and will seek it out once they're not stuck in the welfare trap. There's even a solid chance this will bring civilization to a point where no one needs a minimum income.

Re:Unfit for work by kevinskii on Friday March 22, 2013 @05:33PM (#5425930)
By your logic, it would be perfectly ok for the government to give each of us a billion dollars a year. Is this what you believe? If not, why not?
Re:Unfit for work by mkr-hn on Friday March 22, 2013 @05:34PM (#5425944)
We're talking about basic income for the purpose of ending poverty, not giving people a billion dollars every year for some undefined purpose. Your hypothetical is nonsense.
Re:Unfit for work by sans-serif on Saturday March 23, 2013 @01:15AM (#5427343)
But why not a billion dollars? The worst that happens is someone has more than they need. And then what happens?

One of two things:

1: It sits in the bank, where it's lent out for investment

2: It's spent, possibly on something optional but still legitimately useful and non-frivolous, in which case it flows back out into the economy

I don't see a bad outcome..!

Re:Unfit for work by lilsunnybee on Saturday March 23, 2013 @04:20PM (#5429615)
That would be a massive redistribution of wealth, much more than needed. The billion wouldn't end up being a billion though, due to runaway inflation.
Re:Unfit for work by mkr-hn on Saturday March 23, 2013 @08:16AM (#5427856)
People who win the lottery often end up worse off than when they started. Giving everyone a multiple of the highest lottery winning every year would be destructive.
Re:Unfit for work by kevinskii on Friday March 22, 2013 @07:06PM (#5426350)
Of course it's nonsense. And if you articulate why, I think you would see that your basic income argument is nonsense for mostly the same reason.

I'm probably just preaching to the choir, so you can have the last word if you want it.

Re:Unfit for work by lilsunnybee on Saturday March 23, 2013 @04:27PM (#5429641)
No your point specifically is nonsense, because its a false comparison. Having a basic billion dollars would be massive wealth redistribution, as opposed to minor, and would have many additional negative consequences due to the severity of it.
Re:Unfit for work by mkr-hn on Friday March 22, 2013 @07:35PM (#5426481)
I'm sure there's some useful academic term for what you're doing here.
Re:Unfit for work by lilsunnybee on Saturday March 23, 2013 @04:25PM (#5429633)
Re:Unfit for work by kragen on Friday March 22, 2013 @08:32PM (#5426709)
I think it's called "reasoning" or "logic".
Re:Unfit for work by rictic on Friday March 22, 2013 @11:03PM (#5427090)
mkr-hn's describing (as I read it) redistribution of wealth.

The problem with your suggestion is that it would necessarily create runaway inflation, because there's no way to square that payout with government tax income.

You can have redistribution of wealth without runaway inflation, there are a number of existence proofs of this.