I have a hard time sympathizing with Gitolite being removed for it's complexity. GitLab switching to their own stuff to make their side of the equation easier, to make their software less complex to write and configure, otoh might be a thing. I'd just need nominated yesterday to start trying to install it alongside Gitolite!
I wonder if they made a crack at being able to read and parse gitolite.conf files and use those configs to power gitlab? That would've been a happier path for me personally for smoothing out gitlab configuration hell, more so than writing a new repo server that we're not likely to qualify & then adopt, not when Gitolite is our living beating heart.
Nowaday i expect something to run and have as few steps to install as possible. It wasn't even so much the many steps in between but the stuff that just didn't work as given in the installation guide. Turned out that some answers were in the gitlab Troubleshooting Guide. And then some stuff just didn't work, because at that point resque was removed (if i remember correctly, i don't even know what resque is and i don't really care, tbh). Now, after this took me 2 hours to get it running, half a day was spent with a) log in, b) find something not working, c) google, d) log into server and fix, e) repeat.
I'm no ruby guy, too, but i would've thought this goes much smoother nowadays.
I was using Gitlab for 1 or 2 weeks back then, but when the password reset didn't work it really made me think if i want to go through all that again on the next major update. So i turned to gitblit (which i rejected before because it can't do pull requests).
Edit: Don't get me wrong, i liked the Gitlab interface, it's very polished and nice, and what was working was working fine. Still i wouldn't want to maintain it. Maybe it's all better now with 5.0 :)
I looked at GitLab, Gitolite + gitweb, and Gitosis. GitLab's installation was the worst of the three. It was horrible, and seemed like it would have been impossible to maintain/upgrade. I really hope that the entire experience has improved.
I ended up using Gitosis, and while I don't quite like the workflow, the installation was pretty easy (there was a bash script to run that installed and configured everything).
I'm going to evaluate the new version of GitLab, but if the installation process isn't better, I'll just stick with Gitosis.