Very contrived scenario. No two candidates are perfectly similar.
Further, it is not legal to ask about medical status in an interview, other than job requirements (can you lift 40 pounds, can you stand on your feet for 4 hours).
> No two candidates are perfectly similar.
The scary thing is that many employers would prefer a worse candidate over someone with a known MH illness.
You have 2 candidates for a job. They are entirely similar, except one of them discloses a history of MH problems which they claim are well managed by medication and monthly meetings with a psychiatrist.
Which do you employ?
There have been posts on HN from people saying they'd feel anxious about employing women of child-bearing age, or people who have had MH problems.