News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by sokoloff on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @05:16PM (#542464)
it incentivizes him to hire less talented people

This seems spectacularly unlikely given Joel's other writing and the fact that he's running a profitable company, the profits of which substantially depend on the quality of staff he hires. Saving 1% of payroll and giving up any substantial "edge" in development is a bad trade, and regardless of your opinion of Joel, I suspect he's smart enough to know that.

All the same pathologies seem to remain intact in this system.

All of those same pathologies sound to me like pathologies with the people not the system, and the solution is to just recognize that people who can navigate themselves around small obstacles are actually more valuable. People who complain at year-end about why they couldn't acheive their maximum potential need to be steered into a mindset where next time they find a speedbump to drive over or around it, not to stop and complain about the uneven pavement.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by tptacek on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @05:27PM (#542483)
Two responses:

(1) I agree that it's unlikely that these problems affect Fog Creek in practice --- although how would we know? But the point is, Spolsky wrote this to advocate for a practice in your company, where this formula probably won't help you.

(2) If "people" didn't have irrational issues with salary negotiation, it wouldn't matter how you handled salary negotiation. The purpose of a system like Spolsky's is to neutralize those problems, and it succeeds or fails based on how well it accomplishes that.

Re:Why I Never Let Employees Negotiate a Raise by ashot on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @06:39PM (#542574)
if it is a "bad trade" then the salary levels are wrong by definition