News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Making a low cost interplanetary "weather balloon"? by dalke on Friday March 22, 2013 @12:37PM (#5423983)
What you've outlined is the "Faster, Better, Cheaper" policy. You can read some about that history at http://amyshirateitel.com/2012/03/06/should-nasa-reconsider-... .

The basic problem is that it costs something like $2,000/kg to get something out of earth orbit, and 1 kg doesn't get you much. For example, a literal "ton" of redundant sensors would cost $2 million. Just the launch cost for Galileo (to Jupiter) would have cost $50-$100 million or so of its $1 billion cost.

Instead of having "tons of fuel", the cheaper option is to use complex orbits that take advantage of gravity boosts. This allows more weight for sensors and less for boring fuel. But it can take more time.

There's little need to self-destruct. It's expensive to carry a bomb out to Jupiter. Instead, we 'deorbited' Galileo into the planet when its mission was over.

The spacecraft isn't the only cost. There's also time on the Deep Space Network to be able to send and receive messages with the craft, and people to maintain things and analyze the data.

You could make it cheaper on the ground by using a higher power communication system. However, that makes the craft heavier, which costs more money, and reduces what else the craft can do. Rather than having enough power to transmit flyby data live, it's better to use a lower power system and send the data over several weeks. After all, in most of space there's a whole lot of nothing going on.

There is no drag in space. Shape doesn't make a difference.

You can see now some of why mission planning can be very complicated. More fuel means fewer sensors and less transmission capability, but can make a shorter trip or give more maneuverability at the end. These can all affect the mission goals.

There are no comments on this comment yet.