Re:Google killed me
by alexjeffrey on Friday March 22, 2013 @01:09PM
(#5424177)
it's mentioned in the post that the author reported the facts a number of times.
Re:Google killed me
by The1Mirage on Friday March 22, 2013 @01:38PM
(#5424351)
It has been corrected since then - the post is from February 28th, not sure why it's just now hitting HN.
This isn't a real-time complaint.
You can always check the data in Freebase: http://www.freebase.com/m/09v5l5c?links&lang=en&hist...
Apologies. I posted this because it came up recently in a media blog [insert joke about media being slow].
So it was a manual fix that corrected the issue? I guess that makes since given that her Wikipedia entry didn't have the standardized birthdate listing (at least in the first line) until today (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Amy_Wilentz&ol...). Would that fix alone been enough to fix her snippet?
Re:Google killed me
by Matt_Cutts on Friday March 22, 2013 @06:21PM
(#5426153)
I'm not close enough to know what fixed it, but I agree that the non-standardized birthdate probably didn't help.
As Amy noted in her piece: "My Wikipedia entry, oddly, was put up by Cousin Joel, who has a genealogy obsession .... Joel began the entry with my connection to my father, and immediately mentioned my father’s birthdate and the date of his death."
I wonder how many of these items are manual fixes? It would be interesting to see the number of them adjusting the index.
This seems to be Google SOP for big data sets like this, and for the most part it works okay. The other obvious similarity is Maps. Pull what data you can from easily available sources, and then crowdsource the details or inaccuracies.
Re:Google killed me
by jQueryIsAwesome on Friday March 22, 2013 @09:20PM
(#5426855)
She probably already knows so is somewhat disrespectful that she has not update the entry saying that Google already fixed her public profile.
If you see an error in a Knowledge Panel (the box on the right-hand side), look for the "Feedback / More info" link at the bottom of the box and then you can click next to a fact to report a problem. People do review those reports, and that's the fastest way to report an issue.