You're completely correct, great points. It's very easy to fall into the trap of 'human-like intelligence will fix it' when thinking of better machines, but it's fairly clear that human-like intelligence has a lot of failings too.
even if the hole knowledge graph would be filled out by humans, there would still be errors in it, thats just how it works with this sort of big data. No way you could design a computer algorithm which does this job without a single error
Re:Google killed me
by yaddayadda on Friday March 22, 2013 @01:35PM
(#5424333)
I find perverse pleasure in your ironic error, i.e. a hole in your knowledge (or potentially typing skills) related to the distinction between "hole" and "whole".
I actually tried to imagine a hole-based knowledge graph... it sounds really interesting.
there would always be some holes in the graph
Re:Google killed me
by TazeTSchnitzel on Saturday March 23, 2013 @08:18AM
(#5427859)
AI make more mistakes than humans at some things, but only because, like humans, they are just beginning to understand. I might make similar mistakes reading articles written in German, because I am not yet fully fluent in the language. Similarly, NLP AI is currently not "fluent" in English.
Considering that "non-artificial intelligence" makes the same kind of mistakes, I find that an odd claim.
Mistakes happen. Quite frankly far fewer of them happen in the modern world, due precisely to technology like this. What has changed is actually the converse: automation has become so good that we expect it to be flawless. No one would have found it "surprising" (annoying, sure, unless it was in the context of a zazy madcap comedy film) in 1962 to be mixed up with someone else's biography based on a name confusion.