Re:Apple, wtf is wrong with you?
by sbuk on Thursday March 21, 2013 @03:45AM
(#5413609)
At the risk of down votes, the Mac was "kaput" because of liquid ingress and it only takes a drop on any component to do the damage. The fault my friend lies with you. Honest question, do you think you'd have been treated any better elsewhere?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Unlike Apple (at least the last time my wife bought one), other PC vendors are happy to sell you accidental damage protection with a laptop. I'd say that is a pretty big difference.
At the risk of sounding cynical, that's not for the benefit of the consumer. It doesn't mean much either as most manufacturers I've had experience with will try and wriggle out of honouring those agreements, HP especially. That said, Apple absolutely should offer this facility.
Agreed, the wriggling is an issue. I've always been able to deal with it, but it is frustrating (especially since I primarily run Linux - support is probably the top reason I dual-boot). I've found that I can minimize it by buying the "business-class" laptop and/or the "business-class" warranty, but that is still irritating and a trap for the unwary.
In any case, even with all the wriggling, I've found ADP to be a pretty wonderful investment without even counting the increased peace-of-mind. I'm not sure if I'm just unusually hard on my laptops or if the gap between my repair cost and theirs is so large that it is easy to design a truly mutually beneficial warranty.
Come on, if you really think that a drop of coffee will usually kill any electronics you must have never even handled a circuit board...
Most laptops (including mi MBP!) will survive light spillage without problems.
Depends on what the liquid came into contact with and whether or not it was live. I absolutely think that Apple, or in this case their 'genius' should have done more. With that in mind, the OP should have complained.
EDIT: removed snark.
I was going to tell a story of washing old circuit boards in the breakroom sink at a prior job, but I guess I'll pass. :-)
That said, the air keyboard does have a spill protection layer that provides some measure of protection. My girlfriend has spilled far more liquid on her Air and it's survived well. It's unfortunate that you got a terribly unlucky circuit-seeking drop of liquid.