Then there is the separate question of whether publicly shaming the person as Richards did was an acceptable response. I certainly do not think it was. But it's a separate issue.
The degree of the reaction is completely separate from the degree of the offense?
Consider Oritz vs. Swartz.
If a teenager shoplifts a stereo from a store, and a vigilante witnesses it and shoots him in the head, I think we can all still agree that the teenager was in the wrong. The fact that the vigilante was even more in the wrong doesn't change that.
Because the two offenses aren't separate in the other direction.
Teenager [commits offense], vigilante witness shoots offender in the head.
Where [offense] is A. shoplifts stereo, vs
B. shooting store employees and preparing to shoot innocent bystanders.
If (A) the vigilante is a murderer, if (B) he's a hero.So the ethics of the teenager's action (A or B) can be evaluated on its own, but the REaction of the vigilante can only be judged in the context of the teenager's action. The two actions are not mutually independent. One action is independent, but the other is dependent.
I've been to plenty of conferences and I haven't heard of this happening, except to politicians when they forget there are microphones and news reporters around.
This is why our society does, in fact, have a separate set of privacy rules for people classified as "public figures". So the rest of us can hang out and chat in comfort by assuming in all probability the absence of a news reporter or papparazi trying to play "gotcha" with a camera and microphone.