News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by jerf on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:23PM (#5411367)
Fair use doesn't apply here. Fair use is a defense that can be used if charged with copyright violation that would otherwise be a violation of the copyright. It doesn't relate to trademarks. In terms of trademarks, it simply isn't illegal to mention the product by its trademarked name, so no defense is necessary in the first place as it is not even a valid charge.

Subsequent followup by the company indicates they may have a valid IP claim on other materials (and may not, I don't know and frankly I don't care), but one that the DMCA can't be used to enforce.

Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by will_brown on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:34PM (#5412152)
>In terms of trademarks, it simply isn't illegal to mention the product by its trademarked name, so no defense is necessary in the first place as it is not even a valid charge.

Exactly, see my quote:

"I have to agree the DMCA Notice seems to be embarrassingly improper as an attempt to enforce alleged TM violations."

>Subsequent followup by the company indicates they may have a valid IP claim on other materials

That is exactly why I included the hypothetical legal analysis to assume arguendo that the TMs are also CR[1] or simply other material was CR. See:

"Even assuming the TMs above were actually CRs, it would still be improper to try to enforce a CR when the "alleged" infringement is obviously permissible under the Fair Use Doctrine."

[1] It is not common that a TM to be related and identical to a Copyright - here is an example Nirvana may have a TM for their band name "Nirvana", but may hold CR for their self titled album "Nirvana".

Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by mistercow on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:56PM (#5411619)
I think will_brown's point is that in order for the DMCA to apply, we have to charitably assume that the trademarks are also covered by copyright, in which case fair use would apply.
Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by magicalist on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:17PM (#5412090)
Fair use still doesn't matter in the case of the DMCA. DigitalRev can ignore the takedown notice because they believe that it is fair use, but they then open themselves to liability because they lose their safe harbor protections (or their ISP does. It's not clear to me that a publication has safe harbor over their own articles in the first place, since presumably they are posting their articles with full knowledge that they are posting them...aka the articles aren't user generated content).

GoPro could then sue DigitalRev and/or Softlayer, who could then use fair use as a defense, but it would proceed as in any copyright infringement suit.

This makes sense, since fair use is (mostly) an affirmative defense and has to be decided by a judge. On the other hand, the DMCA procedure gives much more power to the complaining party as they can use takedown requests to silence speech with little to no worry about the enforcement of perjury clauses as long as they can claim they didn't "knowingly materially misrepresent" their claim.

Edit: and to actually get to will_brown's point: it would therefore technically not be improper to serve a takedown notice on something that would be covered by fair use, as technically fair use is infringement (otherwise you wouldn't need a "fair use" of it).

However, the poster could then file a counternotice and get it restored in "not less than 10, nor more than 14, business days". If the complaining party then filed suit (against the poster, not the hoster), they would have to demonstrate infringement and the poster would have to demonstrate fair use (or the judge could throw it out if it was obvious).

It's that 10-14 days of silencing, even if the claimant never plans to file suit, that's the second biggest problem with the take down system (after the complete lack of penalties for that kind of misuse).

Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by will_brown on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @11:45PM (#5412756)
>Edit: and to actually get to will_brown's point: it would therefore technically not be improper to serve a takedown notice on something that would be covered by fair use, as technically fair use is infringement (otherwise you wouldn't need a "fair use" of it).

No that is NOT my point, in fact I specifically said: "it would still be improper to try to enforce a CR when the 'alleged' infringement is obviously permissible under the Fair Use Doctrine". Although I think you knew that and did not intent to include the word "not" in the above statement, in which case, yes, it is improper to send out a DMCA Notice when you know the alleged CR is being used permissibly under Fair Use.

The same logic follows for all CR law, and law in general as a lawyer may not bring a case they know is frivolous or state a claim upon which relief can be granted. Improper behavior of this kind can open the door to Bar complaints against the lawyer; potential causes of action or sanctions against their client; and the awarding of attorney's fees against both the client and attorney personally.

>GoPro could then sue DigitalRev and/or Softlayer, who could then use fair use as a defense, but it would proceed as in any copyright infringement suit.

>If the complaining party then filed suit (against the poster, not the hoster), they would have to demonstrate infringement and the poster would have to demonstrate fair use (or the judge could throw it out if it was obvious).

Yes, Fair Use is a defense that would come into play in Court. However, keep in mind a Judge can award attorneys fees and if any set of facts supports awarding fees it is where: 1.) GoPro is improperly trying to use the DMCA Notice to enforce TM (assume there are valid CR also), 2. I am sure DigitalRev will respond to the DMCA Notice and the record will reflect DigitalRev explained to GoPro why this is Fair Use before any lawsuit was filed and 3.) any reasonable attorney should have known using a CR in a product review is Fair Use.

Thus, Fair Use can be very powerful in the case of a DMCA, even before the case is filed, at least a case with these facts, because it creates a record that the party knew or should have known the case was frivolous before filing. Attorney's know this and must advise their clients accordingly - a party will be less likely to file a CR infringement case if your attorney told is telling you the alleged violation is permissible under Fair Use and as such you are going to be exposed to paying the other parties fees? Moreover, what attorney would expose themselves to sanctions and paying attorney's fees, which they would do their client has nothing but frivolous arguments (not supported by fact or law) why this is not Fair Use? See how powerful alleging Fair Use can be on a DMCA matter before a case is even filed?

Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by magicalist on Thursday March 21, 2013 @03:57AM (#5413654)
> No that is NOT my point, in fact I specifically said: "it would still be improper to try to enforce a CR when the 'alleged' infringement is obviously permissible under the Fair Use Doctrine". Although I think you knew that and did not intent to include the word "not" in the above statement, in which case, yes, it is improper to send out a DMCA Notice when you know the alleged CR is being used permissibly under Fair Use.

Sorry, my response was confusing. By "to actually get to will_brown's point" I meant "to address" your point, because then I did mean to disagree with you :)

I agree with you that fair use is almost certainly considered by attorneys before advising about filing suit, but unfortunately in practice, the repercussions for filing suit while on the wrong side of even obvious fair use are unlikely enough that it often is done.

There are of course always going to be legitimate disagreements over what constitutes "obviously permissible" under fair use, and cases that seem obvious to some will still end up in court.

But there are many, many flagrant abuses of the system, under the same kind of incentives that give us SLAPPs, with the same issues of not enough legal tools to fight them without also having plenty of money to back you up.

For some examples, check out this EFF article[1] after Rush Limbaugh used the DMCA last year to take down clips from his show used to criticize what he said after the whole Sandra Fluke testimony thing. It also includes a host of other examples of people using takedown notices in this way, from Uri Geller to network news programs.

It highlights the example of Michael Savage v the Council on American–Islamic Relations, where Savage did take them all they way to court after the notice/counternotice dance, the judge did dismiss the claims under fair use, but did not award attorneys fees. If CAIR had instead been an individual or a poor advocacy group, it's likely that Michael Savage would still have taken them to court, but there would be huge disincentives for that other party to allow the situation to escalate to that level. Better to not file a counternotice and just accept defeat than go into massive debt (hence the comparison to SLAPPs).

In any case, I do agree with you that that's how the law is structured, and there are likely many ethical lawyers out there going through exactly that decision process, and we never hear about it. My point is merely that, like the "knowingly materially misrepresent" clause in the DMCA, the disincentives to being a bad actor are often toothless (and just the threat of a fight are enough to prevent people from even getting to the stage where they do have any legal remedies), so there are plenty of bad actors. And unfortunately, the people most likely to want to trample fair use rights are also often able to afford a lawyer willing to make forays into expanding intellectual property rights in new directions at only a small to moderate risk.

[1] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/04/limbaugh-copies-michae...

Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by rmc on Thursday March 21, 2013 @05:48AM (#5413948)
(after the complete lack of penalties for that kind of misuse).

Yes, that's one of the biggest problems with the DMCA. It could be solved by only having certain licenced people be allowed send DMCA take-downs (i.e. you need a DMCA licence to send it). All take downs would have to be filed with some central authority. You'd then have X% (e.g. 1%) of all DMCA take downs randomly examined to find misuse. If someone does ridiculusly stupid things, their DMCA licence is revoked. If someone recieves a DMCA take down notice, and they follow the law, they should also be allowed to have it examined to see if it's insane like this. Again, DMCA licences can be revoked. Someone with a DMCA licence will not send stupid take downs since it would affect them.

Initially it shouldn't take much time to examine these cases, since initially you're just looking for stupid cases like this.

Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by mistercow on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @11:05PM (#5412568)
>Edit: and to actually get to will_brown's point: it would therefore technically not be improper to serve a takedown notice on something that would be covered by fair use, as technically fair use is infringement (otherwise you wouldn't need a "fair use" of it).

I do not think that is correct. According to 17 U.S.C. § 107:

Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 17 U.S.C. § 106 and 17 U.S.C. § 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. [Emphasis mine]

Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera... by magicalist on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:30AM (#5413746)
So, this kind of comes down to sloppy wording.

You do need to establish that a party is using something that you have a copyright claim to in a way that violates your exclusive rights as a copyright holder (17 USC § 106), otherwise there's no reason to establish fair use, because you have no grounds to sue for infringement in the first place. However, if you fall under fair use protections, you are not infringing that copyright, because you have "fair use" of that copyrighted work in that particular usage.

However, my point was more what I was getting at in my response to will_brown. Fair use is a determination made by a judge. All you have to do is disagree that the usage of a copyrighted work is fair use, and it is infringement again. Just the threat of a lawsuit (or stretching out a lawsuit through long discovery and threats of appeals) can be enough to stifle speech, and the legal remedies are not many, and are expensive (anti-SLAPP laws are difficult to get right and are not widespread in the US for a reason), without even a strong guarantee that you'll make your money back, let alone your time, stress, etc.

The DMCA in theory has a built in safeguard, but the "knowingly" is so tricky to demonstrate, and any meaningful damages are very difficult to establish in many takedown cases. Moreover, it's been well established in practice that you can get away with many invalid and valid-but-obviously-fair-use takedown notices with no repercussions, even if you were plainly very very wrong. AFAIK, many attorneys won't even try to make a case for that getting damages that way.

For example, the EFF has been fighting for damages in one DMCA case against Universal Media Group that has been going on for six years, and not only has the judge definitively said that the EFF would have to demonstrate "some actual knowledge of misrepresentation” on UMG's part (while also writing that there's no such thing as "self evident" fair use, btw), but, because it was a non-monetized youtube video, the damages that can be won will amount to "at least minimal expenses for electricity to power [Lenz's] computer, Internet and telephone, bills, and the like", while legal fees would be limited to the 4.25 hours spent filing the original counter notice, amounting to $1275 for the EFF[1] since the casework since then have been pro bono.

So it's not improper in the sense that it is how the legal system is actually functioning today.

[1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/01/six-year-old-danc...