News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by potatolicious on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:47PM (#5410166)
> "Startup employees haven't risked as much but their risk is compensated with appropriate equity the earlier they join and the more risk they take on in the form of lower salary and benefits."

This is the part where we wave our hands and drop a smoke bomb.

You're theoretically right, but it never works out that way. For all intents and purposes, in the current state of the tech economy, there is no inherent risk to working for a startup. If my company went belly-up today I'll bounce off the floor juuuust fine.

Equity at this point is not being given in exchange for the risk of the company failing, it's given as a tool to decrease other forms of compensation.

And it's a shitty trade. Founders know it and experienced employees know it. The only people who are falling for this are the fresh-faced college grads who think 0.1% pre-dilution of your startup will make them rich.

But lots of engineers get convinced to take huge pay cuts in exchange for a pittance in equity, and to forego huge amounts of benefits that are worth real cash.

"Compensated with appropriate equity" is bullshit. If this was standard operating procedure we wouldn't be walking around acting like sub-1% pre-dilution is worth anything whatsoever.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by waterlesscloud on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:50PM (#5410191)
I've been amazed the typical equity for early employees has stayed as low as it has for as long as it has.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by doktrin on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @05:11PM (#5410357)
I would replace "early employees" with "early engineers". Not sure why, precisely, but it wouldn't surprise me if negotiating prowess played a role.

Companies I've worked for in the past would never dole out more than 1% to engineers, but dropped anywhere from 2-5% on sales / biz-dev / managers. In one case, the engineers had actually been with the company for years and working at half-market wages prior to the non-technical hires.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by throwawayhooray on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:41PM (#5411009)
Engineers/designers are not as good at negotiating than people in sales/biz-dev.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by seeingfurther on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:55PM (#5410234)
It's going to change.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by seeingfurther on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:52PM (#5410210)
Well if it's a smoke bomb... let's change it. I agree with you there.

I'm a current founder and my first 10 employees are going to get a hell of a lot more than .5%

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by khuey on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:14PM (#5410788)
Are they going to have anti-dilution protection?
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by seeingfurther on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:53PM (#5411111)
Nobody gets anti-dilution protection. Including founders.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by danielweber on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:46PM (#5411932)
By saying "including founders" you make it seem so fair. After all, if there is any benefit, founders should get it, right?

But, founders obviously cannot have anti-dilution prevention. When a company is founded, by definition the founders have 100% of it, and the only way they can raise money is by diluting.

If two founders and three VC reps are sitting around the board table discussing the next round of funding, if there is heavy dilution it will often include stock grants to all the people sitting around the table to reduce their pain. An employee doesn't have a seat sitting around that table, so he is more likely to be pinched by dilution that the founders or the VCs.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by khuey on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:14PM (#5412333)
Well it could work if the amount of stock is effectively fixed at creation time. Everyone I've ever talked to who doesn't already know how stock works is very surprised that more stock can be conjured out of nowhere. They always assume that new stock is formed by subdividing the existing stock (splitting) and that investors get shares that used to belong to the founders.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by seeingfurther on Thursday March 21, 2013 @01:15PM (#5416914)
Before working on startups I worked on Wall Street so I can't look objectively at this statement. If that's really true, it's a failure in our education system. Isn't it crazy that to drive a car in this country we need to take a written and practical exam but to invest our life savings we just open an account. Everyone should be forced to study the series 7 material in high school.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by seeingfurther on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:44PM (#5412208)
I'm not a VC so I can't say I've sat around in the above scenario a million times but I don't think a series B or C involves giving stock grants to founders just to keep their % high and avoid the impact of dilution. (someone correct me if I'm wrong). Every round they get diluted, they've just started out with more. I think the founder advantage might come in to play when a B or C actually liquidates founder shares.

Potentially later stage startups that retain founders as C level executives grant stock but that's a separate distinction I would think.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by danielweber on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:03PM (#5412290)
It's not a matter of course, but if anyone sitting around the board room table has found their investment dwindle away, they will get grants enough to have them stick around.

If you aren't around that board room table, you are SOL.