Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera...
by citricsquid on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:14PM
(#5409923)
If you look at the DigitalRev website you'll see the product widget in the side bar[1], this lists the products they have for sale relevant to the article. Why would a GoPro employee be looking at digitalrev.com? Probably to look at reviews of their products. If they were on that review page and spotted the GoPro being sold with unlicensed images (or whatever the problem is) they're likely to link to the page they were looking at when contacting their lawyers, correct? This seems like an unfortunate oversight; the person that "discovered" the GoPro licensing issue linked to the page they saw it on, not considering the potential confusion because they're linking to an article about GoPro.
Seems like an easy mistake to make.
[1] Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/PWJp2BU.png
Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera...
by jeremysmyth on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:24PM
(#5410001)
That logic might be acceptable if the DMCA takedown mentioned the images. It doesn't. It specifically references the trademarks "GoPro" and "Hero".
Their "clarification" isn't.
Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera...
by yasth on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:59PM
(#5410272)
It should be noted that there is no such thing as a DMCA takedown for trademark infringements.
http://chillingeffects.org/dmca512/faq.cgi#QID569
So yeah pretty much nothing holds up.
Re:GoPro Uses DMCA to Take Down Article Comparing Its Camera...
by analog on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:49PM
(#5412243)
The takedown notice specifically cites the review page, not the product pages, and the product pages are still up [1]. GoPro are lying.
[1] http://www.digitalrev.com/product/gopro-hero3-black-edition/...
If you read the DMCA takedown, you'll see that it refers specifically to the URL of the review, not to any other URL, and certainly not to the location of any product sold on any e-commerce site.
In fact, their e-commerce site still contains GoPro products. http://www.digitalrev.com/search?t=pro&q=gopro
In short, either GoPro are lying through their teeth, or their legal team engaged in a monumental cock-up. In either case, this looks like a clear-cut misuse of the DMCA, a claim that can easily be supported by GoPro's own words, if you take them at face value. I don't.