Re:Jason Fried: Get Satisfaction is "awfully close to blackm...
by Semiapies on Tuesday March 31, 2009 @06:17PM
(#540955)
Libel has to be a lie. Someone harshly laying out their opinion on a business's practices and saying those practices resemble extortion isn't even in the running for libel unless s/he says something factually untrue about those practices. Opinions aren't libelous.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Jason Fried: Get Satisfaction is "awfully close to blackm...
by Gibbon on Tuesday March 31, 2009 @07:07PM
(#541025)
In law, defamation (also called calumny, libel, slander, and vilification) is the communication of a statement that makes a claim, expressly stated or implied to be factual, that may give an individual, business, product, group, government or nation a negative image. It is often, but not always, a requirement that this claim be false, and, or alternatively, that the publication is made to someone other than the person defamed.
Re:Jason Fried: Get Satisfaction is "awfully close to blackm...
by Semiapies on Tuesday March 31, 2009 @07:18PM
(#541033)
Fried didn't post about the private sex lives of people working for Get Satisfaction. He accurately described their operation and characterized it unfavorably.
While the law differs in other parts of the world, in the United States libel has to involve knowingly false statements meant to give someone a negative image.
Making complaints on one's blog and having the party you're complaining about show up, act highly apologetic, and immediately start rewriting parts of their website to address your complaints is about as far from "defamation" as you can get.
Re:Jason Fried: Get Satisfaction is "awfully close to blackm...
by Gibbon on Tuesday March 31, 2009 @07:36PM
(#541049)
Any statement can be grounds for defamation if it can be proved true or false in a court.
A statement made as a fact (for example "The site also hosts, without permission, company support pages for over 14,000 companies.") is potentially actionable.
Re:Jason Fried: Get Satisfaction is "awfully close to blackm...
by Semiapies on Wednesday April 01, 2009 @11:21AM
(#541949)
By your persistence on this point, I assume you're both British (or otherwise only familiar with UK law) and think UK law is relevant on this point.
It's not.
I'll leave you to ponder the question, "If Fried's complaints in his blog post are 'defamatory', what exactly are all the consumer complaints on Get Satisfaction's site, then?"