News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by roc on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:21AM (#5407383)
He's trading heavily on nostalgia and free press for his new game. Talking about Wright, Roberts and Molyneux is a way to stoke the nostalgia, and blanket blasting the industry with contentious quotes is just a way to get that free press. He doesn't have a "point" beyond that. He's not 'right' about anything of substance.

If you actually drilled into Garriott's argument here -- instead of just recording 'bombshells' and briefly trying to establish some room for him to backpedal later -- his argument would dissipate into a lot of hand-waving. Because the particulars are just going to identify exceptions and display a lack of concrete evidence for his view, beyond slinging arrows at designs that 1. he personally doesn't like 2. are beyond any designers' ability to influence (e.g. things handed down, or shortcuts taken due budget/scheduling issues, etc)

Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by saraid216 on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @01:12PM (#5408639)
Eh, he's not wrong about some things, but he's not saying anything new. It's been said before, and it's been said repeatedly for the last decade.

So yeah. PR stunt.

Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by papsosouid on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @01:46PM (#5408892)
>He's not 'right' about anything of substance

He is right that most "game designers" suck, and that the core reason is because they were people who didn't cultivate a real skill, so went through the QA -> level designer -> designer path. A path which doesn't make any sense, and for which there is very little useful training or education available. There is so little analysis of what makes games fun and how to design fun games, and 99% of game designers never see or hear about the little that is available.

Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by roc on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @02:00PM (#5408979)
He gets people nodding along by saying "most stuff sucks". But the absence of examples is intentional. Because while most people will nod along to "most stuff sucks", they do not all agree on what sucks. And that goes for music, games, films, books -- essentially all arts and culture.

Until he actually defines what is and is not good design, he hasn't actually made a point that can even be evaluated.

The bit about the career path is somewhere between ad hominem and red herring. The path is irrelevant to the results. If bad designers are getting through, it'd be due a failure of the filter between level/encounter designer and lead designer. Not a product of whether the level/encounter designer came from QA or development or ops or whatever else.

There's also no way for us to evaluate how much a given 'bad design' was a function of 'no effective training' as opposed to 'time crunch', 'no resources', 'dictate from management', 'tech limitation', or even 'novel theory that just didn't pan out'. And absent that, how could we lay the blame at the feet of career path?

Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by papsosouid on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @02:05PM (#5409013)
Yes, everyone who works in the industry is wrong and doesn't know anything. Good point.
Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by roc on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @03:13PM (#5409480)
Did you miss the part where we don't all agree on what it is that actually sucks?

When I say "most people think most things suck, but they don't agree on what sucks" - that applies to industry people too. And nothing about their being industry people means they magically all agree on what, in particular, sucks nor in what the non-sucky alternative would be.

Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by papsosouid on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:09PM (#5409889)
No, I didn't miss it. It just is a meaningless statement and does nothing to further the conversation.
Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by roc on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @05:53PM (#5410657)
My pointing out Garriott's fallacy doesn't advance the conversation but your repeating it does?

One last time: Garriott's statement is uselessly vague. If we ask people "do most designers suck" we will be lumping together the affirmative answers of those who think (e.g.) Halo's designers suck alongside those who think they do not.

So both groups agreeing to the over-broad phrasing "most designers suck" gives us only the illusion of consensus.

So as long as Garriott avoids defining "what sucks" and "what does not suck", he is not saying anything true or worthwhile.

Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by papsosouid on Thursday March 21, 2013 @09:19AM (#5414785)
No, you don't need to define what sucks. Most people agree that most game designers suck. Most people agree that getting punched in the face sucks. This is not a difficult concept, and trying to pretend the point is "uselessly vague" simply because you don't like it is absolutely useless.
Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by roc on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:23AM (#5415192)
> "This is not a difficult concept"

I'd have thought not, but you seem impervious to it.

Your consensus includes people who disagree on what sucks. How in the world can you pretend their seeming agreement on a broad phrasing remotely matters?

8 out of 10 people might says shooters suck, but if 4 think health packs are the problem and 4 think auto-regen health is the problem and health packs are the solution, they do not agree. The 8 out of 10 number is useless in deciding not only which is the design that sucks and need to change, but in deciding how to change it to not suck.

Saying "most people think most design sucks" is at the level of abstraction of "most people think most human interaction sucks". "getting punched in the face" is a specific, defined human interaction. If you or Garriott wanted to specify an example design at that level of specificity, we could evaluate it.

Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by papsosouid on Thursday March 21, 2013 @12:16PM (#5416189)
You are inventing an imaginary problem so that you can complain about it. Your problem is imaginary, so make your complaints imaginary too.
Re:Richard Garriott on why “most game designers really just ... by roc on Thursday March 21, 2013 @04:25PM (#5418683)
Right, because no-one has ever disagreed on whether a game or game mechanic is good.