News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by Swizec on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:21AM (#5406395)
Here's the deal: There are people who do agile and there are people who talk about doing agile.

The latter is riddled with "process" and is just as bad as waterfall.

The former is a hodgepodge of "whatever has in the past worked for this team and was flexible enough to keep everyone happy while letting us have a modicum of an idea what stage the project is in".

You want to work on the latter. Because it doesn't matter what you call your methodology, what matters is that it works and that issues users care about get fixed.

Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by tomelders on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:55AM (#5406503)
What I personally want to work on is a project where the project manager takes an active interest in where the project is at, by asking for updates and following progress and generally, you know, managing the project.

As opposed to throwing a hissy fit because I've not taken time out of my busy day to fill out forms in whatever third rate piece of junk project management "tool" they've adopted so they can just run a report and pretend they've done their job.

Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by ryanbrunner on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:01AM (#5406532)
Sorry you've been using bad tools. I must have missed the part of the Agile manifesto that requires that you use a shitty project management tool.
Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by tomelders on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:01AM (#5406681)
It's not me choosing to use shitty tools. It's a symptom of agile non-thinkers.
Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by ryanbrunner on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:18AM (#5406748)
Do you mind saying what tool you find so objectionable? There are a LOT of tools out there for project management. Some are absolutely horrible, for sure. Some aren't so bad.

Ignoring that though, I'd say, if anything, Agile promotes using simple tools like wallboards (physical wallboards, with physical cards). I don't really think you can pin using a bad tool on the Agile community when they largely prefer not to use these tools in the first place.

Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by tomelders on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:32AM (#5406800)
When I raise my objections to the crappy tool (Jira in this particular case), I'm greeted with an avalanche about how it's the best tool for Agile.

I absolutely can pin it on the agile community, because if you take the Agile argument away from them, they're left defending a crappy tool with no arguments at all.

Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by Bjartr on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:30AM (#5407434)
As a person using Jira daily in a, fortunately well done, agile environment. I must say I can see how, when used with all the bells and whistles, strictly-enforced-workflow this and work-log that, it would be unbearable, the worst interpretation of Agile used to justify creating a sacrosanct "process" and going against the very core "people over process".

As a bug-tracker shoehorned into doing double duty as a Kanban board, does Jira have rough edges? Sure.

However, used as a slightly more feature-full variant of Trello, as a wall of virtual sticky-notes, as a way to help see if the team improves over time like it should, it's pretty useful.

The moment it becomes an impediment it, well, is an impediment, and should be dealt with accordingly.

Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by prof_hobart on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:20AM (#5406751)
No. It's a symptom of non-thinkers.

They exist in all walks of life and all project processes. Agile is not immune from this, but nor it it any worse.

Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by tomelders on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:37AM (#5407141)
Well I'd counter that it's an off the shelf ideology, so it's already starting off worse. Off the shelf ideologies are only attractive to non-thinkers. Anyone who buys into it is already proven to be a non-thinker by my own standards.
Re:Poor Man’s Agile: Scrum in 5 Simple Steps by prof_hobart on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:30PM (#5410929)
Not sure what you are trying to get at with the phrase "Off the shelf ideology". The fact that other people have thought about this before? If so, I'm not clear why you would think this would be bad - the alternative is convincing yourself that unless you've come up with the idea fully formed yourself, it can't possibly have merit.

I would agree that anyone who blindly follows what someone else has written in a book without bothering to consider whether you really understand it, whether it actually makes sense, and whether it needs to be modified to suit your particular circumstances is clearly not much of a thinker.

But taking and developing ideas originated elsewhere doesn't seem an intrinsically bad thing to be doing.