I wouldn't bill a client for running a scan on them. I would start a scan and do manual testing at the same time, focusing on more intelligent attacks and understanding the application. By the time I am done, the scan would typically kill off a significant number of buggy parameters that I now don't have to test because I already know it's as vulnerable. For some projects, this can be quite substantial. Beyond creating a POC and documenting the issue, I now don't have to spend billable hours on all of that.
The fact that scans consistently find a lot of bugs tell you that clients aren't running tools themselves. They don't know the tools, don't understand the results, don't know how to use them beyond point-and-click. They don't know how to set up macros that validate the session and re-log in, etc.
Although it sounds good to say that they aren't paying you to just run a scanner, the reality is no other reputable testers are doing that either.
Yeah, it was a bit snide, but you were scoffing at testers who do use scanners, and I genuinely think not using them (properly) is a colossal waste of time
It would be fun to have this debate somewhere that wasn't 10 comments deep into an old thread.
I don't actually know you, or who you work for, so please don't think I could be calling you out as a bad tester. We just don't test with automated scanners. We're not the only shop that doesn't use scanners. It's just the way we work.
* which is why we don't charge billable hours to run off-the-shelf tools that our clients could just run themselves,
* I addressed why we don't "augment" with scanners downthread (shortened answer: it's a slippery slope to testers just running scanners),
* Our scoping and rates are dead square in the middle of the market, so if scanners are helping other firms deliver projects more cheaply than us, I don't think the savings are being passed along. (We also don't double- or triple- book consultants on multiple projects, and we don't pay overtime.)
I upvoted you, because while I thought that was a pretty snide way to ask the question, I sure am happy to get to say over and over again how our projects aren't just Burp Scanner results. :)