Re:Bills seek end to farm animal abuse videos
by icebraining on Monday March 18, 2013 @05:28AM
(#5393223)
Anyway, you're going to have a problem proving that plants feel pain
colanderman was that you had to prove they don't before eating them, so I pointed out that until recently, we didn't even know of such elements.
Re:Bills seek end to farm animal abuse videos
by colanderman on Monday March 18, 2013 @09:25AM
(#5393961)
Read my comment more carefully. I didn't make that claim.
I claimed that if you make a distinction in your morality between animals and plants based on their ability to feel pain, you have that duty. (Note that this is a claim about the consistency of a morality, not about one particular moral system.)
If on the other hand your morality does predicate your moral right to eat something based on its ability to feel pain (as our ancestors did), then there is no such duty.
(Of course there is also a grey area between these -- a morality based on a creature's ability to express an experience of pain is more broadly accessible.)
Anyway, you're going to have a problem proving that plants feel pain since they lack all of the elements that cause the experience of pain in animals, such as nerves and brains.