News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by tptacek on Sunday March 17, 2013 @09:28PM (#5391878)
If you want to run scanners all day, we're definitely not a great place to work.

We changed the format for the crypto challenges because:

* the "vulnerable" web app got in the way of what we were trying to teach people (it's easy to work CTR mode into "decrypt this cookie" but not so easy to work Diffie Hellman into that)

* the web parts got repetitive (there's only so many times you can show people "decrypt this cookie" before the "cookie" part of that gets in the way).

* some of the challenges involve implementing crypto constructions (which we found to be the best way to learn how to break them). We had features in 36 Chambers that tried to capture "building" as well as "breaking", but they were extremely clumsy and contrived.

* But mostly, because we'd rather put effort into tech supporting people learning crypto, as opposed to Ruby code running on Heroku.

Sean's crypto stuff has about 2.5x as much material as the 36Chambers crypto-for-pentesters site had, and that's mostly because we stopped wasting our time making it look pretty. The site was a silly way to spend our time. We'll have RC4 keystream bias challenges by the end of next week. If we were going to work them into a shiny web app, we might not have them by the end of the year.

If the pricing model we use for the challenges ("mail Sean and ask for them and he'll give them to you for free") is too much for you, I don't know what to tell you. Yes, making it to the end does incur the penalty of us begging you to come work with us. But if you're unwilling to surrender to a life of indentured servitude in the pentest mines at Matasano, we will happily accept a warrant on the blood of your firstborn child. That is, I think you'll agree, a tiny price to pay.

I guess thanks for giving me a chance to clear up this issue, which, if you follow me on Twitter, has maybe had you confused for awhile (at least until last November or so when we started telling people every damn week to mail Sean for the challenges).

Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by livingontheedge on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:25PM (#5392038)
>"Sean's crypto stuff has about 2.5x as much material as the 36Chambers crypto-for-pentesters site had..."

This site never existed, at least according to Matasano's offical website or Twitter account.

>"If the pricing model we use for the challenges ("mail Sean and ask for them and he'll give them to you for free") is too much for you, I don't know what to tell you"

You are deviating from the fact that you promised to give sth away at a national conference, then completely ignored it until s.b obviously pointed it out. What happened between BH-11 to last November - when you started telling everyone to send email to Sean?

Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by tptacek on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:18PM (#5392236)
Maybe if you keep reframing your questions you'll manage to weave your way past my original evasive answer of "we decided not to do it that way" to the truth of "we grind up the bones of the victims of our free crypto challenges into a fine meal we use to fertilize the fungus patches we rely on for sustenance down in the pentest mines".

"Free" challenges, indeed. Ah hah hah hah hah haaaaaa! Mwrhwprh -gulp-. Mmmm. Fungus.

Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by livingontheedge on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:33PM (#5392283)
What a great response from Matasano founder! No wonder they have 2 Ex-es (daeken,nbpoole) in this thread.
Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by nbpoole on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:46PM (#5392312)
Please don't presume to speak for me. I left Matasano because I was returning to school; I greatly enjoyed my time there and I keep in touch with everyone I worked with because they are a group of intelligent, kind, and all around awesome people.

Also, I wholeheartedly endorse Tom's responses to your insinuations.

Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by daeken on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:47PM (#5392316)
Totally agreed on all counts.
Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by jcr on Monday March 18, 2013 @12:01AM (#5392374)
Cody, you're dealing with a coward that created an anon throw-away account just to troll with offensive remarks. I'm actually surprised how restrained Thomas has been with this jerk.
Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by daeken on Monday March 18, 2013 @12:13AM (#5392407)
It's not the anon that I care about, it's that someone is being an asshole in public to people I consider to be friends, and using my (and nbpoole's) name to do it. I'm not fond of that.
Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by jcr on Monday March 18, 2013 @12:20AM (#5392424)
It bothers me too.
Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2013 @01:26AM (#5392613)
You guys are all great; honestly, though, I think we're the only ones reading this part of the thread, and I was owed some kind of karmic retribution for turning Cody's post into a Matasano hiring thread.

I'm surprised none of you think I'm devious enough to have planted that anonymous commenter, though. "What, you're saying you test ALL the form inputs? What are you, some kind of atomic superman?"

Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2013 @12:11AM (#5392398)
DON'T BELIEVE EITHER OF THEM! THEY ATE THE FUNGUS!
Re:So You Want To Be A Breaker, Part 1: Web Security by erock on Monday March 18, 2013 @09:56AM (#5394140)
The Fungus is made from people!