Could be. Your work description sounds different though. We did use Nessus and Metasploit for some things, but not for web app security, since ALL these tools suck on a web app security level. They do stupid request-response analysis and they usually have no capability to hold some sort of state, which gets increasingly important in modern web apps.
> We avoid tools like sqlmap.
I think there's actually no other tool like sqlmap. Sqlmap is pure gold as a time saver and also capability-wise. Exploiting a blind time-based SQL vulnerability manually is a pain. Why not use a good tool for that?
If you want to be super careful, just hook up Burp between sqlmap and the target host and check every statement manually. Still better than typing it out.
Note for non-security guys: Blind means that you don't get an error message from the host, which should be the default. Time-based means that you craft some SQL statements that take longer than other statements to get an idea which statement is true. So you could ask something like "does user 1 in table 1 start with letter a-f? if so, return it, if not, wait 3 seconds". This way, you get true or false based on the time it takes the host to respond.
Still, if you're interested in web app security, go and try it out. But if you feel you're some sort of pentesting monkey that does the same stuff day-in day-out, better leave and chase something more interesting :)
But there is no tool that will come close to competing with a top-notch pentester on a SQLi hunt. Automated tools just don't cut it. There is nothing like watching First Blood in action.
We do zero government work.
I don't feel like we're along in appsec shops for having this mix. I think one possible difference is between pure appsec shops like us, iSec Partners, IOActive, and Stach & Liu, versus general security practices. The work at general security practices might be more of a drag.
It's also the case that network security, being a race to the bottom (with Nessus and Metasploit "scanner jockies" and the like) is actively trying to push up into appsec. Maybe the web appsec work at a place like that is boring? We take it pretty seriously.
We avoid tools like sqlmap.
I'm answering this on the off chance that the conversation is a good glimpse into the working life of an appsec pentester (since that's what Cody's writing about).