News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waiting for the Accelerator Bubble to Pop by rdl on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:22AM (#5389492)
The only first-hand data I have is seeing the valuations YC companies raise on their notes, vs. what I consider to be fairly comparable teams (if not companies) from 500 Startups and no incubator. The YC companies are maybe 2x 500 Startups, and 3-4x people from outside the Bay Area. Given that a lot of YC teams weren't bay area insiders when they joined YC, it's a no-brainer. (and I'd consider 500 Startups worthwhile in general as well; I just think YC is better)

I think a top FB/Google tech lead who knows investors who leaves to go do a related startup probably doesn't see as much of a bump in valuation from YC as someone who just dropped out of U of Michigan and is living in Ann Arbor, but there are plenty of other reasons why giving up 2-10% to YC is more than worthwhile.

Re:Waiting for the Accelerator Bubble to Pop by niggler on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:25AM (#5389505)
"I think a top FB/Google tech lead who knows investors who leaves to go do a related startup "

I suspect there's a strong selection bias in YC and other incubators (take dropbox, for which Drew is an MIT grad), which probably makes my request for numbers somewhat foolhardy.

Re:Waiting for the Accelerator Bubble to Pop by rdl on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:32AM (#5389528)
I believe the YC application process is an effective filter, but I don't think it particularly needs to be -- I'd be willing to bet that the marginal admit and marginal reject are close enough in quality that YC and its benefits are a major difference in outcome. (It might be a harder problem than elite college admissions, since while you can pretty readily identify top credentials and signs of failure, successful startups are more frequently hidden behind cosmetic flaws (or personal biases) than successful students are hidden in with C/D students with a bad GPA.)

YC has gotten pretty big now relative to a certain part of the startup ecosystem, but look back in 2005-2008 for when YC was smaller, and the success rate of YC companies vs. non-YC companies of that time. It seems pretty good, which warrants the valuations.