You should phrase your comments in the form of a question rather than passing judgement on things you haven't looked into.
I used to do that but then got negative comments from HN. Anyway, the title of the article was a bit provocative, so I hoped answering in the same spirit would not be taken as offensive. It certainly is inspiring to look into CouchDB.
Yeah, the HN headline was stupid. Sadly stupid titles usually get a lot of up votes. By stupid I mean, intended to incite a knee-jerk reaction.
Re:The thrill of a new technology: CouchDB
by jamesbritt on Monday March 30, 2009 @11:38PM
(#539576)
Same seems true of comments. I think I see Tichy's point; if you ask question, you are often ignored, or mocked.
If, however, you make a (willfully) ignorant assertion, people jump at the chance to tell you just how wrong you are.
Not that I want to advocate this approach, but I understand why someone would use it if, in the end, it generates more useful information.
(I think this was discussed elsewhere on HN, with "troll, don't inquire" as a disappointingly effective means of getting information.)
I wasn't trying to troll, I merely answered in the same tone as the submission title. Let's not blow this out of proportion.
Re:The thrill of a new technology: CouchDB
by jamesbritt on Tuesday March 31, 2009 @03:01PM
(#540591)
I didn't mean to suggest you were trolling, just that some folks have found that adopting certain troll-like characteristics is (for better or worse) an effective means of getting informative replies.
Edit: OK, read the CouchDB introduction now. Did not know that the "views" are server side. I have a past as a Java developer, and I have actually come across the "select all, then compute in Java" pattern several times in the real world.