News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 17, 2013 @12:23AM (#5388116)
When a sovereign fails, its banks fail, and private sector losses are virtually assured. The question is who bears the burden. Roughly half the deposits in Cypriot banks, with assets five times its GDP, are of Russian, Greek, or British origin [1]. They were attracted by high deposit rates (roughly double EMU average) and a system tolerant of likely tax evaders.

>"This whole thing is entirely unfair for the people living in Cyprus. The average citizen had nothing to do with the banking sector stocking up on Greek debt, but now they have to pay for it."

Foreign deposits are flighty. The loan-for-austerity solution is too slow. The Cypriot financial minister has already noted "substantial outflows" from banks over the past few weeks [2]. Announcing a future tax would leave the burden exclusively on ordinary Cypriot depositors. This measure was intended to help the Cypriots, not burn them.

Further, the mark-downs on Greek debt is a proximal, but not the root, cause of the problem. The IMF warned Cyprus in 2011 to raise capital levels, potentially by slashing deposit rates - it did not. Ratings agencies chimed in, in 2012, that private sector losses would result if Cyprus did not increase contributions to bank capital. Complicating the situation is that 15-20 percent of Russian bank capital and nearly 10 percent of Russian corporate deposits sit in Cyprus - there was probably external pressure to keep the banks leveraged.

Pre-crisis, Cyprus stood out for its high growth (almost 4%) and low unemployment (low of 3.6% in 2008), despite a falling savings rate, rising labour costs, and a red hot real estate market following its accession into the eurozone in 2004 [3]. Today, we have a zero growth economy with a banking crisis that would have tipped its debt/GDP from 87% to 145%.

Cyprus needs a capital injection equal to half of GDP. This was never going to be painless.

>"So what do investors, businesses, and savvy savers do? They pull their money from banks in the troubled euro countries. No need to take the risk, even if it’s small."

This is unlikely - the EU banking environment is already highly re-patrimonialised. Non-financial corporate and high net worth deposits have already fled to the degree that they can. Domestic depositors are, for better or worse, less flighty (and savvy) than senior bank debt investors - hence the logic for preserving their latter at the expense of the former. Also Cypriot banks have very little senior bank debt (0.3% of assets for Laiki [4]). This is cruel, yes, and I sound with The Economist's criticism of the tax levied on minor accounts (those holding less than €100 000). But forced de-leveraging will be cruel.

Given the political constraints from Deutschland limiting the ability of the European Central Bank to launch into Fed-style monetary base expansion and its Landesbanks preventing euro-wide deposit insurance, the bank regulatory constraints imposed by a country relying on flighty deposits for financial stability, and the economic constraints of a highly-indebted nation in the middle of a geopolitical brouhaha between Greece, Turkey, and Russia slated for near zero growth in the near future, this is not a terrible deal. Note that Iceland, which was in a similar position in 2007, saw its economy crater by nearly 1/3 from 2007 to 2011, or about 9% annually. Peak (2007) to trough (2009), 3/5.

[1] http://blogs.ft.com/beyond-brics/2013/03/13/russias-cyprus-p...

[2] http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/3/83fb0dd2-8802-11e2-b011-00144...

[3] https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.aspx?sk=25382.... 2011 Cypriot IMF Article IV Consultation

[4] http://ftalphaville.ft.com/2013/03/16/1425732/a-stupid-idea-...

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by jpdoctor on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:43AM (#5389323)
> this is not a terrible deal.

Nonsense. The EU just made the depositors junior to the bondholders of the bank! On what planet does that not have permanent implications for trust in the banking system?

Every EU depositor (esp in Greece, Spain and Italy) should start thinking about where to store their money besides the "insured" banks. Hell, with 0% interest in US banks, the FDIC should at least make some high-profile statement saying this would never happen in the US.

Edit: As near as I can tell, Nemo gets the real rationale correct - https://self-evident.org/?p=962

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 17, 2013 @02:39PM (#5390401)
Depositor insurance replaces the bank's credit with the state's. That happened here. It's just that the state's credit is trash. If you are in a country with trashy credit it would be highly advisable to move your funds to the closest Switzerland, Germany, or United States.

Why is the EU promoting such fragmentation? Again, remember there are a lot of political and financial flows constraints here that are unique. Pragmatism must trump principle. The choices to the bailout team were let the Cypriot economy crater by refusing funds, grant funds and watch foreign depositors leave the islanders with 145 percent debt to current GDP, or take rapid measures.

My hope is that this prompts the EMU to finally implement a pooled depositor insurance scheme. The present scheme is akin to each state in the U.S. providing its own depositor insurance.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by justincormack on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:48AM (#5389343)
There are almost no bondholders. The junior bondholders have probably been wiped out, it is unclear. The senior bondholders there are (very few) are secured (covered bonds) which are senior to depositors.
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by jpdoctor on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:17AM (#5389472)
> which are senior to depositors.

Not for any definition of "depositor insurance" that I'm familiar with. The whole point was that the investors of the bank would lose their money first, then a gov't agency would make good on the deposits.

Anything less is a return to the days of unstable swings banking and deflationary depressions. Or perhaps the wizards at the EU thought/didn't care that Cyprus would join Greece in their deflationary depression: But the signal to Spain and Italy is abundantly clear: Anyone who leaves their money in a bank in those countries is not paying attention.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by bitcartel on Sunday March 17, 2013 @02:16PM (#5390298)
I'm sure people across the EU are paying close attention, especially with many financial pundits holding a view that Cyprus is just a guinea pig.

If the people there roll over without too much fuss, stealing directly from deposit holders will become the template for future banking bail-outs.

Bondholders and shareholders of Spanish and Italian banks could then avoid losses on their bad investments by pointing to Cyprus as a shining example of things done right.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by justincormack on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:58AM (#5389629)
Depositor insurance is not about legal seniority in debt, it is about an insurance scheme that is made available (usually funded by a levy on banks). Covered bonds own a specific pool of assets. But the issue now is that there is legal restructuring, or taxes like this, without any bankruptcy, so it is a bit random what happens...
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by jpdoctor on Sunday March 17, 2013 @12:14PM (#5389694)
> Depositor insurance is not about legal seniority in debt

It absolutely is. When a bank fails, the regulating institution steps in and performs the capital restructuring. The statement of depositor insurance is that they are to be made whole, even if the regulatory institution must dip into the depositor insurance fund.

The EU restructured the Cyprus banks, but they did not haircut the bondholders for the difference, as has been done in every other bank failure since the Great Depression.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by bjornsing on Sunday March 17, 2013 @12:41PM (#5389851)
I wholeheartedly agree. And this in my mind is what the whole story comes down to. I've written about it here: http://bit.ly/1103Gkq.

But to summarize, when both the banking system and the government is insolvent it's relatively obvious to me that loses should be imposed in this order:

1. First bank shareholders should be wiped out(!),

2. then junior bondholders,

3. then senior bondholders and uninsured depositors,

4. then government bond holders,

5. and finally, only if the above doesn't cover it, insured deposit holders will have to take a haircut.

What we're seeing now is more or less a jump straight to 5.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by justincormack on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:49PM (#5390174)
There is a full resolution (ie non bankruptcy) proposal in place, due for 2015. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:20...

It should be less arbitrary that the current scheme, where senior bondholders and the ECB are not being touched.

If you look at the balance sheet of Cyprus Laiki half way down http://ftalphaville.ft.com/2013/03/16/1425732/a-stupid-idea-... then you see that debt is almost nothing. There is a lot of central bank (ECB indirectly) money which has not been haircut. The decision to haircut the "insured" depositors was a political one, allegedly made by Cyprus itself.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by bjornsing on Sunday March 17, 2013 @04:21PM (#5390852)
I can well imagine that Cyprus made the controversial decision (to haircut the "insured" depositors) themselves, for political reasons. It's exactly the decision I'd make in Mr Anastasiades' place if I was being strong-armed by a German delegation. The simple reasoning (for me) would be to increase the risk of contagion above and beyond what Germany can accept, so as to maximize the likelihood of Berlin folding and offering better terms.
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by justincormack on Sunday March 17, 2013 @05:39PM (#5391178)
This (registration required) appears to be what happened http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/f890566a-8f24-11e2-a39b-00144feabd...
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by justincormack on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:39PM (#5390125)
No. eg in Cyprus http://www.centralbank.gov.cy/nqcontent.cfm?a_id=8158&la...

"On the activation of the DPS, an announcement is made in the Official Gazette of the Republic of Cyprus and in the local press stating that the member bank is unable to repay its deposits and specifying the manner in which claims could be submitted and the necessary documentary evidence that accompany each claim."

This is not related to the restructuring and payment of creditors (which usually takes years, while deposit insurance pays out quickly). The deposit fund it is true then becomes a creditor and might get some money back later. This happened with eg insured UK depositors in Iceland.

The ECB has not restructured the Cyprus Banks. Cyprus is going to inject equity into them as a going concern, the equity paid for from this tax (and then the equity will be distributed to the taxpayers). This not really restructuring and other models where banks are left as going concerns with arbitrary appropriation of various bonds (somewhat at random it is true) is becoming normal in Europe (eg see SNS Reaal).

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by znowi on Sunday March 17, 2013 @05:01AM (#5388623)
No doubt you know your trade. The problem is that it's more of a witchcraft and the way you smoothly lay things out here in the complex intricacies of the financial sector evades people from the simple fact that the banks fucked up. And the question of who bears the burden is only a question for the banking industry, in how to leverage public funds to cover their losses.
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by tatsuke95 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @09:46AM (#5389152)
>"the simple fact that the banks fucked up"

The banks are run by citizens and funded by citizens. So when the banks "fuck up", it's going to end up on those same citizens. There is no way to isolate losses to some "bank" entity.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by ux500 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:23AM (#5389257)
Yes! Socialized losses and privatized profits! It's "capitalism"!
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by angersock on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:54PM (#5390199)
Er, I'd be rather surprised if some of the banking entities were not established by foreigners and monies not actually coming from their country of operation.

Hell, Harris Bank in Chicago is owned by Bank of Montreal--so, unless I'm grossly misunderstanding the situation, it would be entirely possible for Canadian executives to set policies that could affect clients in the US. That's not those citizens' faults.

I think you have an incorrect view here.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by tatsuke95 on Monday March 18, 2013 @03:23PM (#5396525)
>"I think you have an incorrect view here."

The majority of shares are owned by American citizens and the executive and board are mostly Americans.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by voxfrege on Sunday March 17, 2013 @05:35AM (#5388675)
> Given the political constraints from Deutschland limiting the ability of the European Central Bank to launch into Fed-style monetary base expansion

This is not so. The Bundesbank gets regularly overthrown by the majority in the ECB panel when it comes to decision about this. Respectable Bundes-Bankers have already resigned, because of that.

Thats why the ECB holds billions (i.e. american billions = 1e9) of greek, italian, spain, portugese state debt.

And this despite the fact that the ECB is not allowed to engage in financing states by the treaties. And all this despite the no bailout rule in the treaties. The treaties are not worth more as a piece of used toilet paper, but the politicians cannot understand why the hell people get more and more anti EUR.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by MaysonL on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:36AM (#5389297)
This was an EU country with a bank deposit guarantee similar to the FDIC guarantee. The guarantee is being voided. How many more EU bank deposit guarantees are untrustworthy? How many depositors will choose to no longer trust them? How many banks will be run?

Personally, I don't have a clue as to the answers to those questions, and I doubt that those who are imposing this tax have a clue, either.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by justincormack on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:51AM (#5389352)
Deposit guarantees were designed for one off failures of smallish banks, not systemic debt crises where large proportions of the total debt in a country is worthless. None are trustworthy in this sense, but some countries are worse off than others. Cyprus has a bankrupt government with no access to debt.
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by caf on Sunday March 17, 2013 @04:33PM (#5390920)
This is absolutely true - the deposit guarantee schemes are not a bottomless pit of money, and are nowhere near able to absorb the losses of a widespread series of cascading bank failures.

It seems extremely unwise to publicise this fact, however - which is what this measure does.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by omgyeah on Sunday March 17, 2013 @06:48AM (#5388799)
If you think that Greece and Cyprus are sovereigns, think again.

And Iceland chose not to receive "economic help".

Greece and Cyprus were forced to receive "economic help".

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by tatsuke95 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @09:20AM (#5389089)
Iceland has 300,000 people and a GDP of $12BB. Their economic "choices" and ensuing trajectory are, for practical purposes, irrelevant.
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by lotsofcows on Monday March 18, 2013 @06:15AM (#5393327)
You are aware we're discussing Cyprus here...
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by jonascopenhagen on Sunday March 17, 2013 @09:04AM (#5389061)
Greece and Cyprus were forced to receive "economic help".

Not AFAIK. Their alternatives were just worse.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by mjn on Sunday March 17, 2013 @09:31AM (#5389111)
The people were also consulted to an extent in Greece, though you might say the results were inconclusive. The series of 2012 elections were de-facto a referendum on whether to accept the bailout/austerity or not, since it was the main issue in the campaigns. There were also pro- and anti- parties on both the right and left, allowing people to make that choice independently of their usual political alignment (left voters could choose between PASOK and SYRIZA; right voters could choose between New Democracy and Independent Greeks). If you go by popular vote, the pro-bailout/austerity parties narrowly lost the May election (48-52%) and narrowly won the June election (51-49%).

There's a little bit of subjectivity in assigning those numbers, because a number of pro-bailout/austerity parties were trying as hard as possible to take up tough-sounding, qualified positions, e.g. in the first round Democratic Left was "less" pro- than the others, even though it eventually joined a coalition government that implemented the demanded conditions. So one could argue that Greek sentiment was more anti-bailout/austerity than the results implied, since some people voted for what they thought were moderate anti- parties who turned out to be grudgingly pro- in practice.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by omgyeah on Sunday March 17, 2013 @09:58AM (#5389188)
Now look. Greek politics drama follows:

Party A was in power until 2009.

During the 2009 elections party A said: "Oops! We're screwed! No more money!". Party B said: "No! Party A is lying! There are lots of money!".

Guess who won? That's right: Party B.

0.0000001 seconds later

Party B: "After all there is no money as we thought... But hey! We're in charge now! We'll save you! It's what we do best!". Nobody said that what they do best isn't very nice...

Forward to 2012.

Party B: "Vote us, so that we'll keep saving you with our great plan and our great banker friends!"

Party A: "Noooo!!! Don't vote for Party B! Their plan and their banker friends are baaaaaaaad!!! We have a better solution! A magic solution!"

Guess again who won? That's right: Party A.

0.0000001 seconds later

Party A: "Shit! Actually Party B's plan is the only real plan... But we are in charge now! Why bother to bring back Party B to keep going with their plan? We can do it as well! Probably even better!"

The End.

Desperate people? Yes. Retarded voters? Yes. Incompetent government? Not really. Corrupted government? Most likely.

Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by ikassinopoulos on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:35AM (#5389543)
This is exactly how things work here in Cyprus and Greece for many years now! These very same people now are responsible to handle the bailout money. But we voted for them. They know better...
Re:The madness of the bailout in Cyprus by yannis on Sunday March 17, 2013 @09:23AM (#5389096)
What I would like to see is transparency as how the funds of the bailout would be distributed and how they would be utilized at least for my forced percentage contribution. I am pissed off and at least in my case your assumption that money will not be pulled out of the banks is wrong.