News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by dyno12345 on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:33PM (#5386696)
Silicon Valley has a weird relationship to capitalism. They sometimes like to pretend to themselves that work isn't about money, and the laws of supply and demand shouldn't apply to labor.

You should work for us because, it's, like, really great! You should want to work 55 hours a week because you really want to! The fact that you're creating stockholder wealth is merely incidental.

Every company in the valley seems to pay "market wages" and then complain that there's simply not enough talent out there. It shouldn't be about the money for them. They should want to work here, because it's so great!

People should be paid what's "fair" and should want to work as much as is practical. Some kid out of college should be paid what's fair for them as a person - it's like a moral issue - not according to the value they create for the company, which can be enormous even if it's just a kid of school. And we need rock stars, not warm bodies, even if the gain to the company from hiring each non-rock star is still enormous.

I am familiar with several SV firms that would make like $400,000 per year per new hire, but insist on paying "market wages" based on experience, and then complain it's impossible to find enough people to hire. You think if we were on wall street a firm would hesitate to double someone's salary if the firm thought they could make double that by hiring them? No one in SV wants to compete on pay. Everyone wants to convince themselves that they've created the greatest place on earth to work, and that everyone should work there because it's so great. The fact that they create wealth for the stockholders is a benign coincidence.

If SV ran the retail industry, everyone with the same job titles would make pretty much the same amount of money working at either Saks Fifth Avenue or Old Navy. What if Saks wanted to hire someone away from Old Navy? They would try to convince them that Saks is really great!! Not because Saks could see that it could gain more from the person working for them than at Old Navy than Old Navy would and can therefore pay them more. That's economic efficiency. But it seems kind of crass, doesn't it? You should want to work for us! Because it's so great, and we'll give you a tiny, tiny, tiny percentage of the equity.

What if I went around telling employers I wanted a strict 40 hour work week? How suddenly would they forget about that hiring shortage? Wanting to work less shows you don't care. You should want to work here. Not because by you working here it creates more wealth for us than we're going to pay you. You think that multiple still doesn't apply if someone is working 13% less hours!? But someone who wants to work less doesn't care, and you should want to work and want to work here as much as possible.

I get six dozen recruiter emails a week. All of them sound exactly the same - you should work here because it's so great! None of them want to compete on fundamentals - pay me more and give me more vacation time. How distasteful! As a result I am completely indifferent between all of them. Everyone likes to pretend it's not about money and there is no price curve for labor. It's weird.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by rayiner on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:43PM (#5386734)
> Silicon Valley has a weird relationship to capitalism. They sometimes like to pretend to themselves that work isn't about money, and the laws of supply and demand shouldn't apply to labor.

What's amusing is that SV is also a place bankrolled by VC, and the VC firms don't buy into that stuff at all. They have no problem paying huge bonuses to lure people away Morgan Stanley, Goldman, etc. But you'll rarely hear them espouse for engineers the mantras they believe for financial professionals: you gotta pay those big bonuses if you want to get the "top talent."

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by zenbowman on Saturday March 16, 2013 @11:59PM (#5388062)
Exactly, lol.

Of course they want engineers to be desperate, it's a lot cheaper that way. This idea that the best ideas come from desperation isn't necessarily accurate anyway, builders want to build, its in their blood. It's why I hack on the weekends and played with breadboards and legos as a kid.

Having enough money allows me to focus on doing what I love best: building stuff. I want to be a part of building the Holodeck, paying me less won't make me want it more.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by eli_gottlieb on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:57AM (#5388324)
It's perhaps difficult to quantify the marginal contribution of your latest hire. However, almost all companies are keeping track of their revenue-per-employee, and it's fairly common around here to remark that your company is not yet doing well until that number hits about $200,000/man-year. Apple and Google and the like have about double that.

At that level of revenue, yes, there are taxes and capital costs to pay, but you can also afford damn fine salaries, too.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by bravohippo on Sunday March 17, 2013 @03:18AM (#5388477)
You're my favorite HN poster and I've read all your comments going back tens of pages.

Marry me?

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by eli_gottlieb on Sunday March 17, 2013 @06:39AM (#5388780)
I'm already engaged to someone, and sorry, but I really do feel pretty uncomfortable with open fanboyism. I guess for a better response I might paraphrase Marx: the development of you is the basis for the free development of us.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by bravohippo on Sunday March 17, 2013 @07:26AM (#5388854)
Sorry for the fawning adoration.

But you see I've been reading HN since the beginning and the endless neoliberal bullshit has made me despair for hacker culture--to the point where I'm now embarrassed to tell educated people that I work in the software startup scene. I'm ashamed to call myself a hacker because of the people the word is associated with.

The smartest people I know see only bad things coming from Silicon Valley. I try to convince them that there are a few good hackers out there who can make positive contributions to civilization...

But even the hero Aaron Swartz has a blighted track record because he created reddit--a shitheap that is destroying culture and causing a resurgence in "White Nationalism" aka Nazism.

If you recognize that memes don't matter, reddit's most notable cultural achievement is that it has become the biggest white pride recruiting site on the planet. And this is the legacy of our BEST hacker activist... this is pg's big hack of society.

So your existence on HN has been meaningful. There are other hackers with similar thoughts, but they rarely speak up publicly. The ones that I know have learned to keep quiet or use pseudonyms so they can get by without conflict.

Anyway don't take my fanboyism too seriously.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by eli_gottlieb on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:03AM (#5389198)
Funny thing, Reddit mostly doesn't have an indigenous white-nationalism community. What you see is, mostly, a raid from Stormfront that turned into a permanent infestation owing to Redditors' bizarre notion that the First Amendment guarantees them a right to say anything they want on Reddit without censure or moderation.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by michaelochurch on Saturday March 16, 2013 @10:16PM (#5387722)
It comes down to the MacLeod hierarchy. For a lot more on this, go here: http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2013/02/26/gervais-macle...

Losers (bottom/workers): trade away expectancy and long-term growth for stability and risk reduction. Rationally checked-out. Strategically minimize discomfort.

Clueless (middle/managers): non-strategic, eager people who clean up the mess made by Losers below and Sociopaths above them. Give a lot to the company, get mediocre returns. Losers are actually less "losing", because they know the trade they are making. Clueless expect to be rich, respected, or secure one day but hit a glass ceiling (Effort Thermocline, the highest one can go by working hard rather than smart) and never get it.

Sociopaths (top/executives): strategic and hard-working, but insubordinate and risk seeking. Take the other side of Loser risk-selling and turn it into personal gain. Good at engineering situations so that upside risk goes to them and downside goes to others (often Clueless).

MacLeod Losers are most of the workforce, and it's relatively easy to turn a reliable profit on one. You pay him a pittance X, and he gives you labor worth 1.25X, and at scale you can make a lot of money this way. However, if you're trying to build a brand or reputation quickly and impress people (press/investors) your average* productivity per person matters, not your sum profit. MacLeod Losers, who reliably return a small-but-positive profit for the company, bring that economically unimportant but socially relevant average down.

VC-istan is a world without MacLeod Losers. MacLeod Sociopaths are the investors and tech press and executives who are brought in by VCs after the company's de-risked. But VC-istan startups (founders and employees) are all-Clueless. That's why "you should want to work 55 hours a week because you really want to" in VC-istan. That's why being a "true believer" in the company matters more than being able to do the job. That's why there's such an age discrimination problem. They're looking for Clueless.

What keeps a company or system stable is the Effort Thermocline. It's the interface between Clueless and Sociopaths and it's the point where jobs become easier with increasing rank instead of harder. (Clueless are often oblivious to its existence.) It's the glass ceiling that you can't cross unless you work smart and "get it". The unconditional work ethic of, e.g., the macho brogrammer only gets you to upper-tier Clueless. VC-istan's Effort Thermocline is especially stable because it exists between companies.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by gregpilling on Sunday March 17, 2013 @12:04AM (#5388079)
From your list of positions one might occupy, I find none appealing to me. Since I own the business I work at, does that automatically qualify me to be a sociopath?

Having nice work conditions works for the boss too. Who wants to own a crappy business? I want to go work somewhere nice, and if I am in charge of the place, I think it is then up to me to make it happen.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by rm445 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @08:01AM (#5388940)
Well it suggests you are dedicated and a strategic thinker, but not very subordinate. Presumably in owning your company you have to forgo a certain amount of buddy-ness with your workers for the benefit of the company; that's what's being alluded to.

The linked articles are quite interesting in their entirety: looking at binary values of being strategic, dedicated and subordinate has some interesting implications and avoids the suggestion of amorality and mental disfunction carried by the sociopath tag.

One other claim of the articles is that for certain companies the investors are the (sociopathic) executives and the CxOs are middle-managers under a delusion. Not universal but again food for thought.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by michaelochurch on Sunday March 17, 2013 @11:26AM (#5389508)
The MacLeod organization is dysfunctional and does not apply to all companies. This series of essays is about how not to get a MacLeod pyramid. It turns out to be a complicated topic not amenable to quick solutions. The short answer is... no, you're not a sociopath just because you own the business.

Rank culture (valuing subordinacy above all) is the one with the most pronounced and rigid MacLeod structure. Tough culture (valuing dedication, often to extremes) tends to exist when the company gets a hard-on about culling low performers and Loser/Clueless stability breaks down... but a new proto-Sociopath set uses the enhanced performance standards to take and give bribes and run extortions and they become the new holders of rank.

There are two good cultures-- guild and self-executive-- that don't have MacLeod tiers.

I like the D&D concept of alignment. There's a moral spectrum (good, neutral, evil) and a civil one (lawful, neutral, evil). So there are 9 possible alignments. Most people and especially most organizations are true neutral (meaning neutral in both) in ideology, even if they tend toward the rank culture's lawful evil over time.

The ideal "Organization Man" is morally neutral, and civilly neutral with regard to the greater society's laws, but lawful with respect to the organization's laws. Most organizations can find something to do with lawful and civilly neutral people, but have no idea how to handle the chaotic.

MacLeod Losers tend toward civil neutrality. They're not chaotic enough to feel a need to break rules, but not lawful enough to care about rising in the company, unless they can get the hard currencies (compensation, more freedom, career progress) that actually matter. Lawful people, however, see important positions as a validation in themselves and seek them.

MacLeod Clueless tend to be lawful. Some are lawful good, some are lawful evil; most are lawful neutral.

MacLeod Sociopaths are the people who don't fit: they find the comfort of the Loser world to be false, and the delusions of the Clueless to be laughable. They tend to be chaotic, which creates an up-or-out time pressure on their organizational trajectories.

This doesn't mean they're bad people. Chaotic good are the white-hat "good Sociopaths", and chaotic neutral tend to be gray-hatted but will usually try to be decent.

Chaotic people rise in organizations because they have no other choice. They either need to get into an executive sinecure, or into a special, high-creativity role where their outsized talents (see: convexity) are an asset that overcomes their social deficits.

However, evil people also rise. Neutral evil are the most capable, because they're fluent in law and chaos and have no strong pro- or anti-organizational bias. They can be chaotic when out of power and lawful when in it. However, lawful evil is perhaps the most virulent, because while neutral and chaotic evil can indulge in non-ambitious sadism, lawful evil are driven.

So, organizations end up being run by a chaotic-or-evil set that needs to make itself look like something else, and society doesn't much like or understand them and calls them "sociopaths", but the most interesting subset (chaotic good, chaotic neutral) are not bad people.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by bravohippo on Sunday March 17, 2013 @02:07AM (#5388339)
>Since I own the business I work at, does that automatically qualify me to be a sociopath?

No. The sociopaths are the ones who control the economic system and the bulk of the capital, who, if your company becomes worth anything, will make you an offer you can't refuse and you will no longer be an owner.

If you refuse to be bought out due to some kind of lifestyle ideology, then you're clueless and suffering from Protestant Work Ethic brain damage.

You're describing an instability. You are an instability. The laws of capitalism dictate that your situation as business owner should either set you up as a sociopath maximizing your outcome, or sell the company to a sociopath who can make more money using your company than you're able to make.

If you then could retire but choose not to, you're clueless, because you're enthusiastic about being a cog in a dehumanizing capitalist machine. Only clueless people and sociopaths feel good about that. Clueless people like it because they have no clue, and sociopaths like it because power and destruction is what turns them on.

Personally I just find that most people who willingly engage in commerce without a financial need to do so lack imagination. I do make exceptions for hacker types like pg who seem to believe they are subverting the system with their economic activity, but the line between being a subversive capitalist and being the most deluded sort of clueless person is very fuzzy.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by gregpilling on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:16AM (#5389233)
Wow. Now I have gone from a sociopath to clueless.

Perhaps there are s subset of people that you have not met, or do not understand. I would identify with those people who enjoy work (I must suffer from Protestant Work Ethic brain damage, despite being an atheist), because when I do work I accomplish things, and this accomplishment makes me happy. Why this makes me a clueless sociopath I am not sure, but the several companies I have started in the last 23 years have at least let me live in modest comfort. I could have retired around 30 and lived of passive income but that is really quite boring.

Maybe you should try starting a company since you know so much about it.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by nradov on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:01AM (#5388203)
The main reason that top software developers aren't paid more than market rate is that their true value is almost impossible to accurately quantify. This is less of a problem in the financial services industry where it's relatively easy to measure the profit contribution of an individual investment banker or stockbroker.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by dyno12345 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:52AM (#5388319)
In companies that are generating significant revenue it's pretty easy to tell if a change is profitable or not, and that you could make X more changes worth Y with Z more developers - not even trying to put a price on individual developers, just a typical developer whom may not even need to be a diamond-in-the-rough, rock star, ninja, volcano-surfing lion tamer.

In many business models it's pretty easy to see the value added by a new, average developer at this firm may be way more than it is at other firms in the hiring market, and are irrationally failing to make gains from trade and inefficiently allocating the labor market by refusing to capture the quantity of labor supplied at a higher price point, before of (I think) cultural reasons.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by waterlesscloud on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:07AM (#5388221)
It's hard to quantify precisely, but it's not that hard to quantify in general terms. In general terms, it's a lot more than 0.2%.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by eli_gottlieb on Saturday March 16, 2013 @04:59PM (#5386778)
From God's mouth to yours, brother. If there is a shortage on the labor market, let prices rise and quantities-sold drop, same as anything else!
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by dyno12345 on Sunday March 17, 2013 @01:58AM (#5388326)
I keep hearing about the extreme shortage of software engineers. But why haven't I heard about software engineer salaries skyrocketing?

If supply is short and prices don't rise, something in the market is broken.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by eli_gottlieb on Sunday March 17, 2013 @10:43AM (#5389322)
It's a bit quiet, but salaries have gone up. Hell, they've gone up even just since I graduated college.

When I saw that rise was when I started believing there really is high demand versus the supply. It does happen sometimes.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by bravohippo on Sunday March 17, 2013 @02:48AM (#5388412)
It's called the class war. The ownership class has class consciousness, but the laboring class does not. The ownership class knows when to wink and nudge and how to run a subtle cartel, because they have class consciousness. But the laboring classes don't know how to do this; instead they fight against each other in a race to the bottom.

The market has always been broken. The "free market" is pretty much the biggest myth since Jesus.

Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by eli_gottlieb on Sunday March 17, 2013 @06:31AM (#5388767)
Judging by the vote patterns I see in this topic, the laboring class here does have class consciousness. I get the feeling a lot of start-ups are really just utilizing Ricardo's Law of Rents to reap the full value of the founders' labor without having to rent it out to an external capitalist. As long as that can continue profitably, it will and should.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by jkonowitch on Saturday March 16, 2013 @10:20PM (#5387730)
All of us have different equations with which we evaluate opportunities. An exciting work environment and a chance to build something you believe in may be a perfectly rational reason to work for below-market rates, especially if you take equity, in essence making an investment in the company.
Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’ by epicureanideal on Saturday March 16, 2013 @11:16PM (#5387945)
I have a similar perspective on this issue. I would like to discuss this further. If you are interested please email me. My contact is in my profile. Same invitation is open to anyone else who has the same perspective.