Re:Searching For Beasts In Silicon Valley’s ‘War For Talent’
by crazygringo on Saturday March 16, 2013 @03:25PM
(#5386433)
> Now, of course, you can cash out as soon as the startup has made any significant progress. ... How many startups would be doing better now if all their early people still had to work there for a big payday?
You can also look at it from the other direction: if only a small proportion of people are great at founding startups, then doesn't it make more sense for them to leave early to found other startups? As long as the people left at the first one have the ability to continue the trajectory, I don't see the problem -- and presumably, the people allowing them to cash out don't see the problem either. It's just a more efficient allocation of scarce resources.
> The broader trend of generally increasing pay, ... Before most computer science graduates ever walk across a stage to get their diplomas, they’re set for life.
Why shouldn't they be? If doctors and lawyers are set for life (depending on how you look at it), why shouldn't highly capable engineers be too?
> The result for many engineers and product managers is often a case of arrested development, as they drift from one startup to the next, dabbling in several side-projects, without the ballast of having solved some really hard problems or contributed to a lasting business.
I don't get what's so bad about this. A lot of businesses don't last, period. Side projects are great.
This whole article comes across almost as a lament for where the Real Men Engineers all went -- the ones who would slave away for little money, solving the hardest problems, out of some kind of macho competition, romantically proving their mettle.
But that's ridiculous. As long as engineers play a valuable role in the economy, they should be compensated in accordance.
This whole article seems to be rooted in some kind of anti-change nostalgia. It almost all boils down to the author being annoyed that 24-year-olds are "collecting expensive scotch". If that's what really bothers you, then the problem is with you judging other people's tastes, not with them.
Maybe there's a valuable point somewhere in the article, but it's hard for me to see it with the author's terribly patronizing, the-trouble-with-kids-these-days attitude.
You can also look at it from the other direction: if only a small proportion of people are great at founding startups, then doesn't it make more sense for them to leave early to found other startups? As long as the people left at the first one have the ability to continue the trajectory, I don't see the problem -- and presumably, the people allowing them to cash out don't see the problem either. It's just a more efficient allocation of scarce resources.
> The broader trend of generally increasing pay, ... Before most computer science graduates ever walk across a stage to get their diplomas, they’re set for life.
Why shouldn't they be? If doctors and lawyers are set for life (depending on how you look at it), why shouldn't highly capable engineers be too?
> The result for many engineers and product managers is often a case of arrested development, as they drift from one startup to the next, dabbling in several side-projects, without the ballast of having solved some really hard problems or contributed to a lasting business.
I don't get what's so bad about this. A lot of businesses don't last, period. Side projects are great.
This whole article comes across almost as a lament for where the Real Men Engineers all went -- the ones who would slave away for little money, solving the hardest problems, out of some kind of macho competition, romantically proving their mettle.
But that's ridiculous. As long as engineers play a valuable role in the economy, they should be compensated in accordance.
This whole article seems to be rooted in some kind of anti-change nostalgia. It almost all boils down to the author being annoyed that 24-year-olds are "collecting expensive scotch". If that's what really bothers you, then the problem is with you judging other people's tastes, not with them.
Maybe there's a valuable point somewhere in the article, but it's hard for me to see it with the author's terribly patronizing, the-trouble-with-kids-these-days attitude.