And those charges for blood transfusions: Anyone up for a startup to find the lowest bidder?
The AMA is essentially a guild. Everything it does in the name of quality is also a highly-effective way to keep wages high for its members. And that's hardly a coincidence.
Could an innovative medical school train a particular kind of specialist to be just as effective in half the time, at half the cost? We'll never know, because that kind of innovation is illegal.
The balance between cost and quality is not black and white. Plenty of patients might very well prefer to trade off one for the other. Today they have no choice -- there is only one standard, and the providers have every incentive to make that standard as expensive as possible.
Just reading your quote, though, (I read the comments before the article) I thought that the article was going to talk about how hard it is for even informed people to opt-out of expensive procedures. There was a news story just a week or two ago about a nurse refusing to perform CPR despite 911 demands, but the home the patient was in was set up to explicitly not perform CPR.
Ezra Klein has linked before to "How Doctors Die". Here is the last HN talk about it https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5104430 (it has links to the prior talk on HN) Even doctors have to jump through incredible hoops to avoid ending up getting drastic procedures done on them, and even then there is no guarantee that the doctor in charge won't override your wishes and hook you up instead.
The issue as I see it with healthcare is the the nature of the beast itself. When you are bleeding from the femoral artery, you don't have time to shop around, and you don't know when it will happen. Additionally, it is a rare event, unlike your drive for food.
But modern health care "insurance" also covers the payment of goods and services that do NOT meet sudden and unexpected events. A huge portion of the health care industry services chronic ailments. Hunger could be considered a chronic ailment--it is not urgent, but must be managed at all times.
The notion that everyone should be guaranteed equal health outcomes is a very seductive one, but once you start digging into the details it falls apart quite rapidly.
Falls apart exactly how? Seems to work fine in just about every country that's tried it (which is most of the first world). Mind you, it's not really the health outcome that's guaranteed (obviously that's going to depend on individual constitution, age and lifestyle) but access to the same level of care is seen as a given. In my town recently there was a minor scandal when a pro hockey player showed up with a game injury at a local emergency ward and went to the head of the line. The hospital had to scramble to explain that his injury went through normal triage.
You talk about bankrupting the public, but clearly it's the far more expensive US system that is bankrupting the public (along with providing worse outcomes overall). For those of use who have grown up with publicly funded healthcare, a fully private system seems primitive, barbaric and inhumane equivalent to having firefighting or police services exclusively for those who can afford it.
As for your straw man about a "fully private system", I made no mention of that, nor have I advocated such. I was merely making an isolated point. You can put your pitchforks back in the shed and put down your "libertarianism = somalia!" signs.
Our system is clearly broken, but the idea that other systems aren't also broken in various ways is naive. There's no silver bullet that will solve the problems of cost and access to health care, and that includes the extraordinarily naive idea of just making "government" pay for it all.
But there are other products that we absolutely need to stay alive that don't suffer the runaway prices we see in healthcare.
The best example is food. You can't say no to buying food.
So why don't food sellers have us over a barrel? Because consumers see prices and force the many providers to bid competitively against each other.
My point is that inelastic demand is not the fundamental cause of high costs in healthcare. It has much more to do with the many layers of abstraction we place between patient and provider that prevent price signals from passing through.