News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Haddock: Built because I want web apps to make passwords fun by nostrademons on Sunday March 29, 2009 @03:16PM (#537667)
The name is unfortunate. Haddock is Haskell's documentation generator, which may be familiar to the same techie crowd.

Also - something I learned from working at a big company: For secure memorable passwords, it's better to take a phrase and abbreviate it than to take a couple words and concatenate them together with numbers and symbols. So from "Haddock: Built because I want web apps to make passwords fun", you might get "H:Bb1wwa2mpf", which looks like random noise to any password cracker yet is still reasonably memorable to anyone who remembers the original phrase.

You can get a lot of use out of song lyrics for this, say "Bbmap,dmc2tlbtlwd" from American Pie or "Yccatyl,bycnl" from Hotel California or "Mhfjl2b" from Comfortably Numb. Long, line noise, completely unrecognizable - yet you'll never forget the underlying lyric.

Re:Haddock: Built because I want web apps to make passwords fun by stephencelis on Sunday March 29, 2009 @03:24PM (#537680)
It's unfortunate that Haskell's Haddock wasn't Haddoc or Hadoc. "Haddock" made the most sense to me as a name for a blathering password generator (with those nods to the Marx Bros. and Hergé). I've named the command-line utility "ha-gen", though, to avoid collisions.

And "H:Bb1wwa2mpf" may be more secure than a similar-length haddock password, but its pseudo-acrostic nature is much less digestible to your average user. Meanwhile, with a few potential modifications I outlined, haddock would still be more memorable _and_ just as secure:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=537562

Re:Haddock: Built because I want web apps to make passwords fun by nostrademons on Sunday March 29, 2009 @03:33PM (#537688)
The point's to remember the phrase, not the password. :-) The password is trivially reconstructible from the phrase.

Actually - since any good programmer won't put a maximum length on their passwords, I wonder if it'd be better to get users into the habit of picking really long phrases as passwords. Type in "Haddock: Built because I want webapps to make passwords fun" in the password prompt. Maybe that'll just take too long to input though, each time you want to login.

Re:Haddock: Built because I want web apps to make passwords fun by stephencelis on Sunday March 29, 2009 @03:39PM (#537694)
I have vague memories of acrostics I formed for study in college...and not-so-trivially muddling them ;)

I still agree with you that this kind of phrasal munging is a good method, but I also think haddock has the slight, memorable edge :)