Sadly, the novelty soon wore off, and it turns out the social element is one of the reasons why they enjoy their trading.
In principle, you could make this work over something like video chat, but in practice I just don't see that working.
> We always knew that people bought this wine for fun.
> The buying process, and talking to others about the wine,
> turns out to be part of that fun.
So yes, you can strip out all of the fun bits and come up with a very efficient transaction process, it's just that the customers want the fun bits more.While we are getting better at recommendations, the best salespeople still have a better understanding of what makes you like a product than "people like you also purchased..." algorithms. This may be particularly important in markets that are about different things for different consumers: wine selection may be about taste, or it may be about social signaling. Same is true in the transaction: it may be about the best price, building a relationship, having a relaxing escape (buying cigars, for instance), or any number of other things.
I'm sure Amazon's algorithms often do have a better idea of what I'd enjoy than many of my friends, but friends' recommendations are still more likely to induce me to act than a personalised promo email.