News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by anon1385 on Thursday March 14, 2013 @09:41AM (#5374851)
Nobody forced Google to start up all those loss making services -- which they did to gain positive PR or attempt to stifle competition in those markets -- or buy those companies and shut down their existing products.
Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by setrofim_ on Thursday March 14, 2013 @10:18AM (#5375083)
>which they did to gain positive PR or attempt to stifle competition in those markets -- or buy those companies and shut down their existing products

or, less cynically, to try them out and see what interest they would generate; shutting them down when the interest was not sufficiently great.

Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by atirip on Thursday March 14, 2013 @10:14AM (#5375054)
Stifle competiton? Are you serious? All what Google does is destroying other peoples's businesses for fun - see, we have shitload of money and nothing to do, why we just offer that what you offer, but for free - haha looser.
Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by arrrg on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:57AM (#5375750)
Offering your product for free (which smaller competitors will often not be able to do) can drive the competition out of business and be anti-competitve (i.e. evil).

This is not some absurd thing to say. The only question is whether that happened. (I sort of believe it did, at least on some level.)

That doesn’t make Google super-evil in my eyes, but it’s a mark against them.

Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by icebraining on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:35PM (#5375986)
That's essentially saying that being too competitive is anti-competitive, and frankly, I think it's ridiculous. So what if smaller competitors aren't able to provide the same solutions at the same price? Isn't that why it's called competition? The point is to benefit consumers, not to keep inefficient businesses alive by hurting them.

That said, I think there's some sense in calling anti-competitive when a player lowers the price temporarily, in order to drive out competitors and jack up the prices afterwards. But that's clearly not what happened here.

Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by arrrg on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:45PM (#5376067)
Nah, reducing the price and bringing it back up is not necessary.

It’s anti-competitive if Google Reader on its own wasn’t profitable and Google nevertheless kept it alive (funding it with money from elsewhere in the company), thus killing competitors.

Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by icebraining on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:55PM (#5376141)
Then, does that make Hacker News an anti-competitive move by YCombinator? Does it make Free Software anti-competitive?

Maybe it is, but then I say, hurray for the anti-competitives!

Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by arrrg on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:59PM (#5376601)
No, it doesn’t.

This isn’t a black and white problem.

Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by arindone on Friday March 15, 2013 @01:07PM (#5381604)
Agreed -- anti-competitive law is pretty clear on the fact that scale and market dominance in one market cannot be leveraged to gain significant market share in another market for this exact reason
Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by icebraining on Friday March 15, 2013 @05:37PM (#5383186)
The fact that they have market dominance on another market is immaterial here, they didn't need it to keep Google Reader free. Lots of companies have free online services subsidized by their endeavors, without being dominant. You're posting in one of them right now, for example.
Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by arindone on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @04:36PM (#5410088)
It is absolutely material in competitive and antitrust law. It's not an issue of interpretation or opinion here -- it's applying the same principles that got Microsoft in trouble in the 90's.
Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by riffraff on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:55AM (#5375741)
The fact that google may not be doing doesn't mean this is isn't a known practice, which is actually punished by the law in some places.
Re:Google Petitioned By Fans Of Google Reader To Reconsider ... by pekk on Saturday March 23, 2013 @05:54PM (#5429928)
I think I would rather that companies try things out and then shut them down, rather than never trying anything remotely new or different in extreme fear that they might fail.