His point is that you _should_ be able to get away with that. Precisely because there is no difference between an open network and a cracked one!!!
Yes, there is. An open network means whoever is providing the wifi disclaims all responsibility for how the network is used. Starbuck's may be able to get away with that, as I said, but I don't think the average home user can, unless they have a really unusual ISP. Have you read the fine print in your ISP's terms and conditions?
If the point is that home users should not have to tolerate those kinds of terms and conditions, I don't disagree; but I don't expect it to happen any time soon. :-)
If your wifi is secured and there are open networks nearby, the hacker isn't going to bother trying to hack yours (I assume you're using WPA, not WEP, the latter is so easy to hack now that it doesn't really make a difference). He's going to use one of the open ones. To have a serious chance of having your WPA hacked you would need to have attracted the notice of someone much more determined than your neighborhood porn junkie, someone like the NSA. So I would say the former scenario is much more likely than the latter.
You mean the burden of proof is on you that you secured your network? How can you prove this, because, you know, you can't!
You say you run an open wifi network, so anybody could have downloaded that porn using your wifi? You're a high profile figure and you expect us to believe that? Yeah, right.
We can spin scenarios all day. At the end of the day, I still think that an ordinary person with an ordinary ISP is better off securing their wifi; the likelihood of WPA security being broken is much smaller than the likelihood of someone using your open wifi to do something that your ISP won't like (or worse). Even a high profile figure is, IMO, better off securing their wifi than running an open network for every nutjob who has a fixation on them to use.
For someone in this situation, it's very unfortunate that Google doesn't have this info anymore!
Although historical records would be more dispositive, it isn't difficult to verify that someone is running open wifi now.
All that may be true (though I would argue that, since you use your home connection a lot more than any other, your risk exposure is much greater and therefore it makes sense to have a layered defense there), but it completely misses the point that you are responsible to your ISP for how your internet connection gets used. Starbuck's may be able to say "look, we're a public place, we can't possibly control everything that everybody does on our wifi", and get away with just making people check an "I agree to your terms of use" box when they connect to their wifi. You, as a home user, are not likely to get away with that.
Schneier also says this: "if someone did commit a crime using my network the police might visit, but what better defense is there than the fact that I have an open wireless network? If I enabled wireless security on my network and someone hacked it, I would have a far harder time proving my innocence." This seems backwards to me: if you have enabled wireless security, you know exactly who you have authorized access to--it's whoever you gave your passphrase to. So it's easy to distinguish authorized from unauthorized use. If you leave your wifi open and someone uses it for something nefarious, how can you defend yourself? You're still liable for the use of your internet connection, and you can't say the use was unauthorized because, well, you left your wifi open for anyone to use.