In Windows, 'X' "makes no sense", while in OS X, 'X' is "clear." Okay, got it :).
Re:The Era of Symbol Fonts
by Samuel_Michon on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @03:10PM
(#5364194)
In isolation, you could say Windows and OS X both use an X on a red background (on mouseover). However, we're not talking about just one button and one hover state, it's part of a set of three (plus hover states).
'Cat, Dog, Rabbit' makes sense, 'Cat, Sonic boom, Carpentry' does not.
Also, even if people didn't understand the traffic light metaphor, a quick mouseover would clear it up: if you hover over the red button, it turns into a (X), if you hover over the yellow button, it turns into a (–), if you hover over the green button, it turns into a (+).