News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-IMF Official: the U.S. is coming to resemble Argentina... by fauigerzigerk on Saturday March 28, 2009 @04:43AM (#536322)
I think he is wrong. My perception is that the US government is very aware of the fundamental issue that is the US current account deficit. Yes the low savings rate of the recent decade is a huge problem, but right now the savings rate is rising at an incredible pace.

Accepting the savings rate and current account balance must be brought back to a sustainable level does not mean the current turbulent readjustment should not be counteracted. This is not inconsistency, it's a timing issue. Ignoring this fact is plain populism, which doesn't surprise me coming from a fellow at a Rpublican think tank.

Secondly, the comparison to Russia in particular is ridiculous. Russia is uniquely dependent on oil and gas. Looking back at Russia's depression and its current troubles, it's hard to ignore the correlation with crude prices (http://www.wtrg.com/oil_graphs/oilprice1947.gif). Oil revenues pay for everything in Russia.

There's another unique feature in the comparison to emerging market crises that he ignores. All these Asian and Latin American countries were indebted in foreign currency and much of their troubles were connected to rapidly changing exchange rates that increased their debt. The US debt, however, is USD debt. The US cannot default on USD debt as the government can print money and inflate the debt away. That's what the Chinese are so scared of.

Also, the US has a huge domestic market, a very broad industrial basis as well as an unrivaled culture of innovation and entrepreneurship.

The current crisis is bad and there are indeed huge issues to overcome. The crisis will continue, but comparisons with the Asian crisis of 1997 or the Russia of 1998 are meaningless. If things should go catastrophically wrong in the US, they will do so in a unique way, not based on some emerging markets template from the 90s.

There are no comments on this comment yet.