Barenholtz pointed out that Boston Cab also has a smart phone app,
but nevertheless has to comply with industry regulations.What Uber is doing is interesting but there are real problems that need to be addressed, labelling every opponent in the business as "idiots" ignores the problems. Let's say hypothetically Uber becomes the biggest source of taxis in Boston, they drive out the incumbent "idiot" companies[1] that can't compete with the service Uber provides and then once Uber has an 80% market share they decide to increase their prices 50%? They decide to ban rides of less than 1 mile because that is hurting their bottom line? They decide that if you want to ride in an Uber cab you need to provide ID and have your fingerprints taken in case of crime? If they're a company built around ignoring regulations and have effectively killed all alternatives, then what? People can't just boycott Uber, because they have no other choices.
The current taxi companies cannot compete with Uber; if they try to they will lose their licenses to operate and they're not big enough to swallow the losses and evolve into an Uber alternative... by ignoring regulations Uber is making it impossible for anyone to compete. The regulations now are not perfect, as many articles have explained there are problems with them (such as restricted licensing to operate, huge start up costs...) but just ignoring them is not the solution.
As others have pointed out in this thread, there are ways to innovate within the taxi business while respecting the regulations and there are businesses doing that now, if Uber wants to genuinely protect consumer interests in the long term they should be pushing for the regulations to be addressed; not ignoring them and putting consumers at risk in the long term.
[1] Companies that have identified the regulations as not being perfect.
How do you capture the market in taxi rides in an unregulated market? It isn't like a telecom where there is only so much physical infrastructure.
Its very unlikely that customers will complain if a law isn't framed and they are enjoying a benefit. Customers will complain later though, once something goes wrong.
Uber (or whoever does Uber's PR) does a fantastic job of making every single one of their legal problems look the same. They really aren't.
I find the two companies to be really interesting: they're both competing for roughly the same space (especially now Uber switched to a meter rate model in Boston), but Hailo takes a much more 'softly softly' approach. I suspect one reason for this is that Hailo's been co-founded by taxi drivers, so they're probably more sympathetic to existing market concerns.
Decisions to bury important information like the legal reasons of why the taxi companies are suing is why I think that most media companies are fundamentally broken.
I'm no student of journalism, but shouldn't best practice include guidelines like: "Make the best case for every side of an argument as soon as possible in an article. Do not bury important points that could be made early on in order to force the reader to turn the page or give the impression that one side is being favored."
"The taxi company argues Uber operates a taxi service without bothering with any of the rules and regulations that govern the industry."
I too hate the page breaks in order to get more eyes on more adds - but this article seems fairly balanced to me.
I still think that slanting articles - whether it's to get ad views or whether it's to express the bias of the reporter/publication is highly unethical and should be called out wherever possible.
I just can't fathom why these idiot cab companies wouldn't just copy the service that Uber provides, which is a really basic idea nowadays.
Build an app that summons your cab. Problem solved. Competitor thwarted. Stop trying to hide behind lawsuits or you'll end up just like these sad sacks in the music business.