Vayable (YC12) - coney island tour (first page)
HelloFax (YC11) - fax (first page), google fax #4,
Lanyrd.com (YC11) - mobile conferences #1, ux conferences #2, + hundreds of other high value kws
TutorSpree (YC11) - tutor (first page), private tutoring #1,
ZeroCater (YC11) - catering in sf (first page)
MailGun (YC12) - email api (first page)
With some time, I could easily find better examples.
What you'll notice with these is that they are succeeding not by trying to rank for a handful of keywords, but hundreds or thousands of keywords. Organize and curate a collection of useful content of interest to your customers, and you will get Google to rank it. Most large aggregations of fill-in-the-blank are not well SEO optimized.
If I were building something, I'd look at a niche outside of travel, real estate, and employment, and create an aggregation around that.
Look at dogvacay.com -- launched in March 2012 ranked #1 for "dog boarding" in many markets.
(1) Can you provide an example of a business with over 100k in revenues that has been founded in the last 2-3 years in a remotely competitive niche and is at or near the top of the search results for the most likely general search terms? How about a bootstrapped business?
(2) And can you honestly say that the mass of blogspam that regularly hits HN disguised as business advice is really high-quality content?