News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antibiotic resistance 'a time-bomb' by enraged_camel on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:10PM (#5358565)
I think another huge trend worth noting is the use of anti-bacterial products. They do nothing other than killing a large portion of both good and bad bacteria indiscriminately and leaving a small, drug-resistant strain, which then does not have to compete for resources with all the non-resistant bacteria and reproduces freely to ultimately make people sick.
Re:Antibiotic resistance 'a time-bomb' by sliverstorm on Monday March 11, 2013 @05:42PM (#5359336)
I think most of those products are anti-bacterial by virtue of things like extremely high alcohol content. I could be wrong, but I don't expect bacteria to develop a resistance to 93% ethyl alcohol any more than I expect bleach- or hydrochloric- resistant bacteria.
Re:Antibiotic resistance 'a time-bomb' by jadyoyster on Monday March 11, 2013 @06:51PM (#5359354)
IIRC most of these anti-bacterial soaps contain this stuff: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triclosan

It doesn't seem to lead to resistance either, but that doesn't make using those products any more sensible.

Re:Antibiotic resistance 'a time-bomb' by ScottBurson on Monday March 11, 2013 @08:22PM (#5359377)
Yes, the big problem with triclosan is that it's a water pollutant. This is why I've stopped using it.

That said, I think the concerns about antibacterial hand soaps leading to resistance are overblown. The bacteria on your hands are not an isolated population; you're exchanging bacteria with the environment all the time. Applying intermittent selection pressure to a tiny fraction of a population at a time causes little if any genetic drift in the entire population.

Say you wash your hands with triclosan soap, and all but a few bacteria are killed. When those bacteria are transferred to a doorknob, say, they have no advantage against the other bacteria that are already there; indeed, whatever mutation allowed them to survive the triclosan probably puts them at a disadvantage in a triclosan-free environment. Even the ones that stay on your hands don't have a competitive advantage against newcomers until the next time you wash.

Conversely, the bacteria in your body are an isolated population. When you subject them to strong selection pressure by taking an antibiotic, if any manage to develop a little resistance, they continue to have an advantage as long as you're taking it. If you don't take enough to kill them despite their resistance, you'll wind up with a pretty pure population that has this new level of resistance. Pass that to a few other people, and repeat the process a few thousand times, and you have a problem.