News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by camus on Monday March 11, 2013 @07:54AM (#5356120)
Why are we using the expression SEO since there is only one search engine people are targetting/using ? do businesses really care if they are numero uno on Bing or duckduckgo ? I never understood that.

Let's cut the crap , SEO is Google rank optimization.

It means there is no SEO since the only player that decides how SEO works is google. If tomorrow Google decides using the word "FLOWER" in your header improves your rank on its search engine, what optimisation are we talking about ?this is not optimization , it is following google's rules. It means google is in charge, and they are abusing their dominant position pretty well, and the whole system is a scam anyway.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by oinksoft on Monday March 11, 2013 @08:17AM (#5356194)
IF Google were to bias in favor of "FLOWER" while disregarding content relevance, it would be an abuse of their dominant market position. But from the outside looking in, it seems like Google strives for nothing but providing the most relevant search results for their users. Controversies tend to arise when Google tries too hard, it seems, localizing based on fragile heuristics and such.

If this is the scam, what's the alternative? An open search engine, perhaps, where development, ranking algorithms, etc. are completely out in the open. I'm not sure this is realistic any time soon though given the cost of hosting a search engine.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by cbeach on Monday March 11, 2013 @09:07AM (#5356407)
A search engine that ranks mainly on social-graph recommendation might be one solution, because the social graph is a simple data structure that transcends "ownership" by Facebook or Google+. The engine itself is a non-trivial system to implement, mind you.
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by Silhouette on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:40PM (#5357874)
The trouble with this idea is that Google can't magically see private links/recommendations on social networks any more than anyone else can.

For example, one site I help with has just a few inbound links from low PR sites as far as Google is concerned, and gets a page rank of zero accordingly. In reality, it probably gets more inbound links via social networking in a single day on most days, and unsurprisingly those personal recommendations often drive more inbound traffic than any search engine.

Google's basic premise of ranking the importance of a site based on how many links it gets and where from is wildly inaccurate in the era of social networking. Normal people mostly don't run their own public web sites or blogs any more, they share stuff on sites like Facebook and often only with their "friends".

Personally, I think this is a good thing, because both as a visitor and as someone running sites I would rather rely on legitimate personal recommendations from people who are genuinely interested in a site than on some arbitrary algorithm running in a data centre somewhere on another continent. I don't think it's healthy for any one intermediary to have a dominant effect on whether interested people can find interesting content on the Web, and sites like search engines and social networks are merely intermediaries.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by pseut on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:51PM (#5358413)
> Google's basic premise of ranking the importance of a site based on how many links it gets and where from is wildly inaccurate in the era of social networking. Normal people mostly don't run their own public web sites or blogs any more, they share stuff on sites like Facebook and often only with their "friends".

I'm not sure that I understand this point. I thought that Google wants to index Twitter (for example) but is prohibited by Twitter. So it's hard to see that their premise is wrong: personal recommendations on social networks are just inbound links from specific sites, just not sites that Google can index.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by Silhouette on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:00PM (#5358890)
I'm sure Google would like to index all kinds of private content, but since they can't see it, they can't index it. Moreover, a lot of public forums based on user-generated content automatically annotate their links so they don't contribute to page rank either; this is done for sensible reasons to prevent blatant spamming, but does mean that a lot of legitimate positive links also don't count. This combination undermines the entire idea that a page rank based on the quality and quantity of incoming links that Google can see and will count is a good indicator of the value of a site.

In other news, searching for things on Google increasingly seems to turn up large, commercial sites first and only to reach smaller, more personal, and often more informative/less biased sites several pages down. Meanwhile, posting a question to my friends on any private forum we share will often get better results within a few minutes anyway.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by bones6 on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:51PM (#5358411)
In your example, I see it like this: Google sees those links and gives low page rank but quantity helps too. So if you're getting a bunch of links on social media, it follows that eventually people will blog about it (crawlable content) and link back to the site. Sure it may be a crappy blogger blog but it's legit and Google does count that. Over time a ton of non-spam PR0 backlinks can and will help rank for search terms. Of course, getting some big PageRank links will help a lot more and if you have any say in the matter, can help with what keyword you rank for.
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by Silhouette on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:13PM (#5358966)
I guess my point is that, talking generally now rather than about any one specific site, we just don't need to put as much weight as perhaps we used to on what Google think of our pages this week. More and more of our traffic comes from personal mentions, passed on by people who are actually interested in what we have to their friends with similar interests, and people who find us that way are far more likely to be genuinely interested themselves and to enjoy our material, increase our income, or otherwise match whatever we created the site for.

People use buzzwords like "going viral", but really this is just the same old exponential growth of word-of-mouth recommendations for good products, speeded up thanks to modern communication technologies and the social networks they support.

Obviously we still make our sites accessible to search engines. It's not like it's difficult to do that if you've got real content and a sensible information architecture, and after all, a bit of extra traffic never hurt anyone. Maybe, if an enthusiastic person finds us that way, it could even seed a new network of people finding us.

But I see this becoming less and less of a priority and dedicated search engines becoming less and less relevant for a lot of sites as people learn to use social networks to spread the word. In particular, I don't see cbeach's original idea of a "search engine that ranks mainly on social-graph recommendation" adding much value in that scenario, simply because the social networks will probably offer similar functionality without needing a third party anyway.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by duskwuff on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:57PM (#5357998)
You're assuming that social-graph recommendations are somehow not gameable. If anything, they're even easier to game than Google search results on current social networks -- there are tons of sites out there that'll offer to "sell" you Likes on Facebook for a page of your choosing.
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by carbocation on Monday March 11, 2013 @08:35AM (#5356264)
> Let's cut the crap , SEO is Google rank optimization.

That's not true in Russia, China, etc. And even in the West, dominating the rankings for your segment in the competing search engines could be extremely lucrative.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by ericcholis on Monday March 11, 2013 @08:14AM (#5356188)
Sorry, this is way to broad of a generalization. Yes, "SEO" is a bit of muddied term. Yes, people target Google first. However, there are quite a bit of standard practices that aren't Google specific that need to be followed. Schema.org and Sitemaps.org are great examples.

Also, a serious business would be kidding themselves if they thought that targeting engines like Bing wasn't important. Reaching customers is important.

With that being said, Google is the biggest player in the game. This means they can make up whatever rules they see fit. However, one of the biggest SEO "secrets" has nothing to do with Google:

"Build for readability, good content that fits your targeted keywords."

Again, this is a general rule, and only a starting point.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by greyman on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:11AM (#5356776)
No, people also do optimization for Bing (you can Google about it ;-)), and also in certain countries, local search engine can be a good source of traffic, so there is a SEO for that as well. But Google is usually most important, that's right.
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by jiggy2011 on Monday March 11, 2013 @08:47AM (#5356322)
Calling yourself a "Google optimization consultant" or whatever might run the risk of trademark issues.

You also might care if you get to #1 in bing. Sure it's nowhere near as well used as google in terms of % but it still adds up to several million eyeballs.

Being #1 on bing for some search term that is super competitive on google is likely to bring a huge amount of traffic.

Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by Encosia on Monday March 11, 2013 @09:41AM (#5356583)
That's probably true for most of us here, but definitely not for every demographic. My personal blog that focuses on software development gets almost all of its search traffic from Google, as you'd expect. However, you might be surprised that a consumer focused site I run only gets 55% of its search traffic from Google (and this site gets more total search traffic than my blog, which does pretty well itself).
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by the1 on Monday March 11, 2013 @08:20AM (#5356208)
eh? what about baidu?
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by camus on Monday March 11, 2013 @08:35AM (#5356263)
you have a point , sorry i'm a bit western-centric. There is also yandex , yet it doesnt really make sense for non chinese or non russian centered businesses to invest in Yandex or Baidu ranking. I live in europe , few have heard of Bing for instance, so Yandex , or Baidu ... it is like Alpha Centauri to them ...
Re:Sick of SEO Scumbags by jiggy2011 on Monday March 11, 2013 @09:31AM (#5356507)
Unless you have a business that targets people all over the world. Like a software business.