News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leading Neuroscientist Says Kurzweil Singularity Predicti... by Retric on Sunday March 10, 2013 @06:48PM (#5353884)
The "singularity" is never going to happen because it assumes intelegence is a single thing that can be increased with more processing power and better algorithms. Completely ignoring things like information theory, over fitting, insanity, training data, and chaos theory.

We can and probably will build reasonably general AI, but you far more likely to see each generation of AI being an ever smaller improvement than any sort of runaway exponential progression. Not to mention hardware progress has slowed to a relative standstill.

Re:Leading Neuroscientist Says Kurzweil Singularity Predicti... by joe_the_user on Sunday March 10, 2013 @07:01PM (#5353943)
Suppose one has the means to build a flexible General AI with modern silicon technology. How could this not result in a thing whose abilities couldn't then be continuously increased at the rate regular silicon technology increased?

The whole "diminishing returns will stop us" just seems like a comforting fairy tale for those who don't want to think about the consequences (which I suspect a bit of thought does show won't be as rosy as Kurzweill imagines).

Edit: Hardware progress is still mostly following "Moore's Law". The only that's not increasing is processor speed. But if we build a "reasonably general AI", how could that box's capacities not be increased by tightly integration with other similarly intelligent boxes?

Re:Leading Neuroscientist Says Kurzweil Singularity Predicti... by Retric on Sunday March 10, 2013 @07:14PM (#5353996)
When a dumb AI comes up with the correct answer using a smart AI is not going to give you a better answer the old one is still correct. However, it could give you a wrong answer for whatever reason. As to diminishing returns, there is a window between a self driving car that's better than people and a 'perfect' self driving car but clearly that's a diminishing return situation, because it was giving you the perfect answer 99.99% of the time there is not a lot of room for improvement.

PS: S curves often look like exponential curves but the real world has real limits so you can't have unlimited exponential progression of any type period end of story. And it looks like we are on the down slope when it comes to transistors. http://www.extremetech.com/computing/123529-nvidia-deeply-un... "Nvidia deeply unhappy with TSMC, claims 20nm essentially worthless" And that's for video cards which are embarrassingly parallel.