News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What made SQL databases so popular? by skore on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:58PM (#5352749)
> True. You can also make good programs in PHP* if you "do it right". it's not exactly promoted or encouraged, or even anywhere on the radar though, and doing so involves a fair bit of that relational logic being implemented and enforced in the client.

It seems while you see that you're making a concession, you fail to understand that that actually disproves your own point. I repeat: Your argument is invalid.

> The point is, it's possible to have a "relational database management system" which enforces the relational axioms for you.

People aren't saying that it's impossible - they're saying it's a question of practicality, with the most true to the abstract concept being the least practical in real world applications.

> SQL is fundamentally incompatible with this concept, and forces the programmer to keep the databases relational.

What?

* By the way: Classic case of "doubting, supported by not looking". Even for PHP, there are plenty of resources like http://www.phptherightway.com/ and they are widely known and shared amongst people who know their stuff.

Re:Ask HN: What made SQL databases so popular? by TheZenPsycho on Sunday March 10, 2013 @07:36PM (#5354085)
There is a difference between "SQL is relational" and "SQL can be used to maintain a relational database". the first is false, the second is true.

As for whether it's practical to have a relational database system, are you claiming that it isn't ?

Re: PHP. I said that PHP can be used to make good programs. Is this a point you disagree with? or, do you see some other point?