News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by andyl on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:35PM (#5352666)
"Silicon Valley loves to talk big about innovation; it's just not as good at following through."

BS. Computing, Networking, Biotech, Internet, and more. Silicon Valley has delivered, and there is more to come.

Not every new investment is going to change the world. But collectively, the track record is very strong.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by potatolicious on Sunday March 10, 2013 @02:03PM (#5352769)
"Very strong" and "more to come"?

Pray tell, what in the following lists qualify as the sort of "big innovations" we're talking about?

[1] http://a16z.com/portfolio/

[2] http://firstround.com/companies/

[3] http://www.kpcb.com/companies

Don't get me wrong, these lists contain a lot of great products that I'm happy exist - but big and world-changing they are not. The fact that the typical SV VC scene funds one or two truly disruptive, technologically groundbreaking firms in a sea of other investments doesn't seem like a "strong track record".

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by pbiggar on Sunday March 10, 2013 @02:45PM (#5352950)
Big innovations from those lists (which I call things that are - or are intended to be - life-changing for a reasonably large number of people):

airbnb, asana, box, facebook, github, meteor, picloud, pinterest, skype, stripe, twitter, uber, yourmechanic, discourse, fundersclub, hoteltonight, mint, onekingslane, simple, square, taskrabbit, coursera, groupon, nest, spotify,

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by potatolicious on Sunday March 10, 2013 @03:28PM (#5353114)
The way I look at it, there are three classes of companies when we talk about this issue. There's the "changes the landscape of the world" level, there's the "massive disruption to a segment", and then there's "incremental improvement on something".

None of the companies in this list are, IMO, in the first class. Self-driving cars, insulin injections, freedom from oil, eradication of common diseases, the internet, semiconductors, the smartphone, etc, IMO all fall under this category.

The second class is where I see AirBnb, Facebook, Square, and the such. They've turned their respective industries upside down with something genuinely different and new (as opposed to simply executing better at lower cost).

IMO the majority of your list belongs in the third class - they're great products, but ultimately they are incremental improvements in their field and have not shown themselves to be disruptive. How has Pinterest changed the world? Or Groupon?

Funny anecdote about Groupon - I've talked to some small business owners way back when Groupon was at the tip of everyone's tongues, and it was never perceived as a disruptive force. Business owners considered them an evolution of coupon books, and treated it as a new, alternative marketing channel - it was never truly disruptive.

The whole point of the original post is that we're funding an ocean of "class 3" companies, a small handful of "class 2" ones, and basically none in class 1.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by 10098 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @06:23PM (#5353795)
Github? Seriously?!

I'm sorry, this just completely blows my mind. I'd understand if you called git innovation (though the real innovation is distributed version control, and it existed before git, git is just a very good implementation), but calling github "innovation" seriously lowers the bar for that concept.

I mean, I love github, but come on, they aren't even the first ones to come up with the idea. SourceForge existed years before them.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by pbiggar on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:55PM (#5354309)
If you think that sourceforge and github are equivalent, you are very mistaken.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by 10098 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:05PM (#5354337)
While they are not equivalent, they serve to achieve similar goals, and it's fair to compare one to the other. Github may be better, but it's not the point. People will be using github to do the same stuff they used to do on SourceForge. Where's the innovation?
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by pbiggar on Sunday March 10, 2013 @09:17PM (#5354365)
Sourceforge is to GitHub as Friendster is to Facebook.

Yes, they are kinda the same idea, but GitHub realized that the social element was key, and managed to create a community around open source the way that sourceforge never did (and, I would argue, didn't even know to do).

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by pron on Sunday March 10, 2013 @03:05PM (#5353029)
Many of these products may change the lives of a large number of people -- but not by much (though some may have a larger effect than others). So while they might be innovations, I wouldn't call them big. In fact, I think it might be a lot easier to change the lives of many by only a little, than to greatly impact the lives of even a few.

I used to feel very strongly about this issue of aiming for truly big stuff, and I agree that increased government involvement (and increased trust of government) is necessary, but I think that doing something really big is just... hard, and very few people can do that. Even large government projects require those rare visionaries. But SV and the startup ecosystem have put the power to make a small change in the hands of many people, and that's quite an achievement. Now we only have to come up with a way to find the few out of those that are truly capable of doing the big things, and help them along.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by silverlake on Sunday March 10, 2013 @04:55PM (#5353421)
I wouldn't consider any of these "innovations." Your definition implies successful == innovative. By that standard Justin Bieber's music is innovative and modern jazz is not.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by pbiggar on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:56PM (#5354314)
I didnt just pick the successful ones, I went for the ones who changed the world in some way.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by jQueryIsAwesome on Sunday March 10, 2013 @02:53PM (#5352985)
For many many people github introduced them to GIT and many of them would still don't know about it if it wasn't for it.

Twitter is a more accessible version of RSS feed allowing way easier access to subjects of interest for non-tech-savvy people.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by pbiggar on Sunday March 10, 2013 @03:02PM (#5353017)
I think you're underselling twitter: its a completely new communication mechanism by which people can communicate short thoughts directly to their followers. It can be used as a better RSS, but that doesn't account for all the other ways it can be used, everything from celebrity gossip, to starting and managing violent revolutions.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by eurleif on Sunday March 10, 2013 @03:03PM (#5353019)
Huh? RSS couldn't be used to spread celebrity gossip, or news about a violent revolution?
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by pbiggar on Sunday March 10, 2013 @08:57PM (#5354317)
I could spread celebrity gossip by telegram; that doesn't mean twitter didnt create something innovative.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by devdas on Sunday March 10, 2013 @07:02PM (#5353946)
IRC over HTTP would be a better analogy?
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by jrmenon on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:50PM (#5352718)
Almost all the ones you listed have had a large role of the Government in play (ARPANET, DOD etc.. not to mention indirectly via research grants to universities). To claim that is all free-markets, and entirely done by 'innovative' private companies is at best a myopic view.

Just fyi, I truly believe in free-markets but I am willing to ack. that it rests on strong foundations in a 'common infrastructure', and with few exceptions, innovations entirely from private entities are limited.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by return0 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:54PM (#5352732)
And it's not limited to the US government.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by jw_ on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:48PM (#5352712)
You are aware that all the technology you mention was initially produced by government-funded research or research labs in monopolies (Bell), no?
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by andyl on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:54PM (#5352737)
Yes very aware, and applaud the role of government in fostering innovation. IMHO we need more govt investment and industrial policy not less.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by trotsky on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:44PM (#5352696)
do you really believe those things were created in or by silicon valley?

Even beyond their public pasts, their early private champions like Bell Labs, BBN and IBM weren't from california nor private equity backed.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by rayiner on Sunday March 10, 2013 @02:08PM (#5352786)
Well Xerox PARC was in Palo Alto, though Xerox itself is based on Rochester, NY. And Xerox was of course not a VC-backed company. Intel, however, was founded in Santa Clara and was VC-backed. Though your point is well-taken. I think big corporate R&D labs are responsible for far more of the innovation we see in the internet sector than VC-backed Silicon Valley companies.

If we're talking about narratives, indeed, the narrative that seems more prevalent is actually a big company that has a cash cow (e.g. Xerox with copiers, AT&T with the telephone network) having money to throw around at R&D activity.

Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by joonix on Sunday March 10, 2013 @06:14PM (#5353747)
IBM Watson is IMO a huge embarrassment for SV.
Re:The hypocrisy in Silicon Valley's big talk on innovation by anigbrowl on Sunday March 10, 2013 @02:32PM (#5352889)
I agree, and think big innovation can result from simple goals - adjusting my lights or heating via a smartphone app is a 'small problem' but an 'internet of things', ie an ecosystem of tiny and cheap embedded computing, will be important in multiple ways, from energy efficiency to AI.

that said, there is an awful lot of wank about. I console myself with the thought that it was probably always like that; for every invention like the telegraph there were three people flogging 'galvanick spirit communicators,' questionable beauty treatments, or silly toys. For every Atari there's also a Chuck E. Cheese :-)