Re:A new type of piano keyboard: The Seaboard
by shardling on Sunday March 10, 2013 @12:10PM
(#5352380)
A guitar or piano isn't MIDI compatible, and that hardly matters.
If the instrument could really stand on its own, then compatibility isn't a problem.
Re:A new type of piano keyboard: The Seaboard
by smosher on Sunday March 10, 2013 @01:05PM
(#5352570)
Sure, but when you depend on synthesis compatibility is a big deal. History seems to support that, with respect to other novel electronic instruments. I was just now responding to a claim that this will work with existing synthesizers.
While I would like to have this kind of control, I would much rather have the flexibility that a standard MIDI keyboard with aftertouch affords with respect to synthesis.
It is midi compatible, it just uses 10 separate channels.
Re:A new type of piano keyboard: The Seaboard
by smosher on Sunday March 10, 2013 @07:56PM
(#5354151)
Which is utterly useless in a 1:1 channel:instrument configuration. Most of my MIDI hardware expects to listen on a single channel, as does most I've come across.
My plugin/VST host doesn't know about this either, so I would need to assign 10 different MIDI channels and all 10 CCs every time I want to change instruments. And for those instruments without a per-note bend, I would need to create 10 instances as well.
How exactly do you expect to get this to work with your existing tools? It's obviously not usefully MIDI-compatible.