News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What made SQL databases so popular? by emin_gun_sirer on Sunday March 10, 2013 @10:52AM (#5352119)
>NoSQL is almost always less powerful abstractly but easier to scale.

This is no longer true. We now have second-generation NoSQL data stores that provide strong consistency, fault-tolerance and ACID transactions, based on the sharded NoSQL architecture that scales easily.

Re:Ask HN: What made SQL databases so popular? by michaelochurch on Sunday March 10, 2013 @03:27PM (#5353112)
Excellent points. Still, "powerful" is defined by client needs (especially performance) and client needs are based on 30 years of expectations derived from the relational model (even if most clients have no idea that's what they want).

If you're exposed to the accretion of business requirements you do not control, you'll eventually be pushed toward a definition of "power" that relational databases meet the best... except when the dataset gets large.

What you say is still true, of course, and will only become more true over time. As more work is put into technologies, they tend to become more well-rounded. Languages that used to have awful performance (100x C) are now closer to 3-5x, for one example. The best NoSQLs now have many of the traditionally relational benefits, and the best relational databases (e.g. PostgreSQL) are overcoming traditional deficits associated with "relational".

Re:Ask HN: What made SQL databases so popular? by ucee054 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @05:44PM (#5353623)
Just out of interest, how are your opinions on the superiority of NoSQL systems received by

http://www.cs.cornell.edu/johannes/

and

http://www.cs.cornell.edu/annual_report/99-00/Demers.htm

?

Re:Ask HN: What made SQL databases so popular? by emin_gun_sirer on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:25AM (#5357280)
All I can say is "some of my best friends have worked on RDBMSs." I don't hold it against them. ;-)

More seriously: Al, Johannes, and many other notable researchers in the DB space have complex, nuanced opinions on NoSQL systems. And these opinions are being revised daily as new information comes in; we've seen some researchers go from decrying the whole NoSQL movement to becoming some of its fiercest proponents, seemingly overnight. I would do them disservice if I were to try to present them here.

So I'd encourage you to ask them directly. Or perhaps we could have a panel at a conference. That'd be fun if done right.