News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Friday March 27, 2009 @10:57AM (#535142)
> it seems that America still has the edge.

Please don't mince words about freedom in China, a brutally repressive state: It doesn't deserve it.

* You can't leave your village without a pass

* You can't have more than one kid

* No freedom of expression

* Oh, and that ongoing massacre in Tibet

Re:Is China the New America? by cglee on Friday March 27, 2009 @11:38AM (#535226)
* I've never heard of the village pass restriction.

* You can have more than one kid - you have to pay a fine though. Also, the restriction doesn't apply to ethnic minorities or farmers.

* You cannot organize dissenting political views. You can express yourself creatively, artistically, etc all you want. Check out Beijing's 798 district: http://www.798space.com (one of my favorite places).

* It's not an "ongoing massacre". It may be oppression, racism, discrimination, segregation, confining a people to internment or a reservation - but to describe it as an active massacre is inaccurate.

Re:Is China the New America? by menloparkbum on Friday March 27, 2009 @12:45PM (#535343)
I've never heard of the village pass restriction.

He's probably referring to the hukou system.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hukou_system

Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Friday March 27, 2009 @03:50PM (#535632)
Thanks, I've long wondered about the specific name for the system. That article is a very interesting read, and the comparisons to Apartheid are apt.
Re:Is China the New America? by cglee on Saturday March 28, 2009 @04:38PM (#536755)
I'm well aware of the HuKuo system (most of my extended family live in China). It doesn't restrict movements at all, and you can move to any city you wish for work, vacation, wandering, whatever. It's just a zip code system to track where people live. I don't know the exact process, but you can have your HuKuo changed if you want to move (of course, you have to go through the requisite paperwork).

There are a lot of injustices in China to be angry about, but I don't think this is one of them.

Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Friday March 27, 2009 @12:03PM (#535263)
* Read about it. I will post some sources here ASAP.

* Is that any less perverse?

* The right to organize with other dissenters is critical in the fight for freedom.

- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03...

- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03...

- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03...

- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03...

- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03...

Those are from the past month in the Post alone.

* Do you mean to say that scores of Tibetan protesters were not beaten and/or shot dead in the months leading up to the Olympics? Because that's news to me.

[deleted]
Re:Is China the New America? by tokenadult on Friday March 27, 2009 @02:35PM (#535539)
Shall I post for you the numerous articles of people in places like Minneapolis or Denver or New York that were arrested or beaten for protesting around campaign conventions?

St. Paul, really, not Minneapolis. I live in the state where both cities are. I see a lot of news video of what the "protesters" were doing, and the police response was appropriate, in my opinion. I am very able in this state to vote out a current administration (not something someone can do in China) and to speak up about my opinion on any issue.

[deleted]
Re:Is China the New America? by menloparkbum on Friday March 27, 2009 @05:10PM (#535725)
St. Paul, yes, sorry to not give the Minni's twin is due credit ;)

Off topic, but St. Paul and surrounding suburbs are actually much more conservative than Minneapolis and the suburbs on its side. It's like the difference between Boston and Cambridge.

Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Friday March 27, 2009 @02:40PM (#535545)
That's the real difference: You can get pissed about these injustices in America without disappearing. Government accountability is tremendously important in American culture.
Re:Is China the New America? by cglee on Friday March 27, 2009 @03:16PM (#535585)
That's the problem you're facing. You're trying to understand China from an American perspective. And it may not be your fault, maybe that's all the perspective you have at the moment.

To understand the complexity of China's problems, and to try to propose a solution, you're going to have to try to understand China at a much deeper level.

Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Friday March 27, 2009 @03:28PM (#535603)
Sorry, I'm too optimistic to believe that people having "certain unalienable rights" is an American phenomenon.

And I didn't even bring other important notions, such as the freedom of religion, into the fold:

http://www.cfr.org/publication/16272/religion_in_china.html#...

Re:Is China the New America? by cglee on Friday March 27, 2009 @04:25PM (#535676)
The best line I've heard wrt giving Westerners a perspective to understanding China is this (paraphrasing):

Americans demand change when they feel something isn't right. They want to see change happen and want it immediately - or, at the least, every four years. It's a young country, barely 250 years old, and has reinvented itself many times over, in short durations, and has grown and evolved so much so quickly. Because Americans can change and remake itself so quickly, they also demand that of others. America is like the hare. China, on the other hand, is like the turtle. It's a 5,000 year old civilization, moving slowly and gradually, at its own pace, regardless of what others are doing. To the Chinese, the last 20 years has been probably the most progressive 20 years in China's history. To China, it is moving at lightening pace. Compared to China 10, 15, 20 years ago, it has come a long long way. And it will continue to progress, but at its own turtle's pace.

Re:Is China the New America? by tokenadult on Friday March 27, 2009 @04:59PM (#535712)
The students who protested in Tian An Men Square in 1989 (some of whom I know quite well) don't expect China to be so slow. They have been disappointed to see that its change has been slower than they hoped back then, but Americans were disappointed back at the time of the Boston Massacre too.
Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Friday March 27, 2009 @04:53PM (#535708)
That's in interesting analogy. Once again, call me an optimist, but human rights aren't something to be patient about.
Re:Is China the New America? by rjprins on Friday March 27, 2009 @08:20PM (#535936)
Well get impatient about yor own human rights problems in the black ghetto's and US prisons.
Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Saturday March 28, 2009 @10:23AM (#536466)
I'm an activist for prison reform. Happy now?
Re:Is China the New America? by erlanger on Friday March 27, 2009 @01:51PM (#535477)
> Your original post was racist,

Because I totally applied my criticism to a people rather than a national government, right? Maybe you're the old-world type that equates nations with races.

Re:Is China the New America? by cglee on Friday March 27, 2009 @12:52PM (#535356)
I don't want to play this game. All I'm trying to say is it doesn't seem like you understand China well, and should reserve criticism until you have some basic understanding of her problems.
Re:Is China the New America? by jhancock on Friday March 27, 2009 @01:02PM (#535373)
agreed..I'm not interested in saying much more either. If this were any other forum, I wouldn't bother replying to erlanger's statements.
Re:Is China the New America? by stcredzero on Friday March 27, 2009 @11:03AM (#535154)
As for Tibet, it is quite similar to what we did to the Native Americans, the Chinese are just doing it more quickly.
Re:Is China the New America? by jacoblyles on Friday March 27, 2009 @11:27AM (#535201)
I think the Chinese view the Tibetan mission as one of colonization and modernization, while violently putting down groups opposed to Chinese rule. Their internal media, at least, views it as a humanitarian mission, not genocide.

Don't know who's right. Could anyone point out information that China's goal is the elimination of the Tibetan people, instead of rule over them? Seems like they could have finished by now if they just wanted to kill them all.

Re:Is China the New America? by stcredzero on Friday March 27, 2009 @11:39AM (#535227)
There were also "humanitarian" justifications with the Native American situation.
Re:Is China the New America? by jacoblyles on Friday March 27, 2009 @11:42AM (#535233)
Sure. I'm just asking for some factual clarification here. Is the point of the Chinese mission to rule Tibetans, or to kill them all? Neither is a nice thing to do, but there is a difference in degree of how mean they are.
Re:Is China the New America? by stcredzero on Friday March 27, 2009 @12:40PM (#535323)
It's not just to rule, but also to obliterate their "inferior" culture. So we Americans did more killing, ideologically, we aren't much different.
Re:Is China the New America? by asciilifeform on Friday March 27, 2009 @12:43PM (#535331)
I suggest reading about how the Tibetans ran their country before the Chinese invasion.
Re:Is China the New America? by nutmeg on Friday March 27, 2009 @11:16AM (#535179)
That doesn't make it any more right
Re:Is China the New America? by randallsquared on Friday March 27, 2009 @12:22PM (#535284)
I think he was trying to say it wasn't more wrong, which carries a different connotation.
Re:Is China the New America? by catz on Friday March 27, 2009 @03:26PM (#535595)
> * You can't leave your village without a pass

There are valid practical reasons for this. Infrastructure such as roads, hospitals, schools, etc... can simply not cater for a massive influx of people from rural areas.

The alternative to this is probably giant slum cities that surround every major city (as what happens in other parts of the world).

> * You can't have more than one kid

Although this is horrible - and things such as forced abortions is heretic there are good reasons for this.

There are huge overpopulation problems in China. Culturally many people are also inclined to get more children (since children traditionally cared for parents and were an old fashioned "retirement plan").

I would go further and argue that the rapid increase in population is responsible for much of Africa's non-development.

> * No freedom of expression

Between personal freedom and economic freedom I would prefer economic freedom. Of course China is not a democracy with all the nice associated things (freedom of expression, etc...).

However, if China were a democracy it would probably have succumbed to a kleptocratic leftist rule - as 95% of other 3rd world countries.