Where 'pretentious' designers do begin to huff is when it is used in a clearly inappropriately context such as on police notices raising awareness of rape.
The handwriting example isn't particularly good because learning calligraphy is a skill that I assume takes a decent amount of time to reach proficiency in. Making a couple of extra clicks in a word processor and selecting something like Arial is not.
Those inappropriate uses involving Comic Sans may be more funny, but other than that, it's hard to argue pretentious designers have not had a bit too much fun bagging on Comic Sans simply out of schadenfreude.
In these cases the intended audience is children, where Comic Sans is totally okay.
[1]: http://inappropriatecomicsans.tumblr.com/image/19581183110
[2]: http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m1m7zmD2ot1rs2h1co1_500.pn...
[3]: http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m135odVzpV1rs2h1co1_500.pn...
Really, I've always been a defender of comic sans as appropriate where the intent is to be casual or personal.
One critical comment by a BBC article reader:
"The main problem I have with Comic Sans is that it makes everything written in it look like a parish newsletter pinned to a noticeboard outside the local church."
Exactly. Isn't that the point?
Criticizing this font is like criticizing a 5 year old child's handwriting on a birthday card, and asking why he didn't have professionally calligraphy.