Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B...
by rayiner on Saturday March 09, 2013 @12:28PM
(#5348976)
> These specifically say that while there may be a distinction between individual free speech rights and corporate free speech rights, the First Amendment applies to both. This "hyper-legalistic" argument from Supreme the Court is different than your statement, which is that corporate free speech is identical to individual free speech.
That's precisely the opposite of what it says: "The First Amendment prohibits Congress from fining or jailing citizens, or associations of citizens, for engaging in political speech, but Austin’s antidistortion rationale would permit the Government to ban political speech because the speaker is an association with a corporate form."
This quotation clearly treats "corporate speech" not as a distinct kind of speech, but as merely the speech of an "association[] of citizens" (individuals) in "association with a corporate form."
> Instead, it says that all "speakers" are covered under the 1st
The way to read this consistently with the previous statement you quoted is that "all speakers" means "all speakers, regardless of association."
The distinction between 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) non-profits here is irrelevant. First, see: http://www.asaecenter.org/Resources/whitepaperdetail.cfm?Ite.... Second, nothing in the government's argument in support of McCain-Feinghold would have been limited to speech specifically in support of or against a candidate, or in lobbying specifically. Indeed, the law at issue in Citizens United was broader than that--it prohibited speech merely mentioning a candidate. The movie at issue didn't say "vote for Hilary Clinton" or "vote against Hilary Clinton"--it was a documentary about Hilary Clinton.
501(c)(3)'s may have certain restrictions in how they use their money to lobby candidates, but the government in Citizens United was claiming a broader power than that--the power the subject of the speech of organizations of people (corporations and labor unions). I can't find a practical distinction between a prohibition on speech "mentioning a particular candidate" and a prohibition on speech "mentioning a hot political issue." The government in Citizens United was claiming the power to ban Sierra Club from talking about mountain top coal removal or the ACLU from talking about drone warfare.
When liberals talk about corporations vis-a-vis Citizens United, they only think about the "bad guys" (BP, Haliburton, etc). But guess what: the "good guys" (EFF, ACLU, Amnesty International, Sierra Club) are all corporations too! What Citizens United, rightly, says is that the government can't regulate the speech of individuals just because they are affiliated with these corporate forms.
That's precisely the opposite of what it says: "The First Amendment prohibits Congress from fining or jailing citizens, or associations of citizens, for engaging in political speech, but Austin’s antidistortion rationale would permit the Government to ban political speech because the speaker is an association with a corporate form."
This quotation clearly treats "corporate speech" not as a distinct kind of speech, but as merely the speech of an "association[] of citizens" (individuals) in "association with a corporate form."
> Instead, it says that all "speakers" are covered under the 1st
The way to read this consistently with the previous statement you quoted is that "all speakers" means "all speakers, regardless of association."
The distinction between 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) non-profits here is irrelevant. First, see: http://www.asaecenter.org/Resources/whitepaperdetail.cfm?Ite.... Second, nothing in the government's argument in support of McCain-Feinghold would have been limited to speech specifically in support of or against a candidate, or in lobbying specifically. Indeed, the law at issue in Citizens United was broader than that--it prohibited speech merely mentioning a candidate. The movie at issue didn't say "vote for Hilary Clinton" or "vote against Hilary Clinton"--it was a documentary about Hilary Clinton.
501(c)(3)'s may have certain restrictions in how they use their money to lobby candidates, but the government in Citizens United was claiming a broader power than that--the power the subject of the speech of organizations of people (corporations and labor unions). I can't find a practical distinction between a prohibition on speech "mentioning a particular candidate" and a prohibition on speech "mentioning a hot political issue." The government in Citizens United was claiming the power to ban Sierra Club from talking about mountain top coal removal or the ACLU from talking about drone warfare.
When liberals talk about corporations vis-a-vis Citizens United, they only think about the "bad guys" (BP, Haliburton, etc). But guess what: the "good guys" (EFF, ACLU, Amnesty International, Sierra Club) are all corporations too! What Citizens United, rightly, says is that the government can't regulate the speech of individuals just because they are affiliated with these corporate forms.