News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by dantheman on Saturday March 09, 2013 @02:07AM (#5347688)
The gist of it is, is that you don't lose your rights when your get together in a group.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by rosser on Saturday March 09, 2013 @04:20AM (#5347926)
I'd find that argument a lot more compelling if the speech afforded the group (corporation) by its 1st Amendment rights were a reflection of the will and judgement of the members — that is, everyone at the corporation, and not, as seems so often to be the case, merely an extension of its owners speech rights.

Corporations are incredible concentrators of wealth, and consequently power, and those concentrations of wealth and power can espouse actions and principles that are frequently at odds with the well-being of that corporation's employees — the very people whose speech the Citizens United ruling purports to prevent being curtailed. Witness the allegations during the last Presidential election cycle of a mining company in Ohio (Murray Energy) requiring its employees to use an unpaid workday to attend a Romney rally — or lose their jobs.

How, exactly, is such "group speech" at all reflective of the political views of that group's membership?

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by crusso on Saturday March 09, 2013 @10:40AM (#5348633)
Name the large group of people in an organization that DOES NOT concentrate the power hierarchically?

Corporations have CEOs and boards of directors. Non-profits do likewise. Large Newspapers have the owners and chief editors. Unions have Union Bosses and various types of decision boards. Churches have Popes, Cardinals, etc.

People often group together PRECISELY TO CONCENTRATE POWER. Why is it surprising? Why should Corporations be singled out for special treatment?

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by rosser on Saturday March 09, 2013 @04:00PM (#5349616)
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but it seriously sounds to me like you're arguing, "This is how we've always done it..." If so, two things:

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_fallacy

2. In our history as a species, that same (fallacious) argument could have been, and almost certainly was used to support slavery, human sacrifice, and genocide, among other charming and socially redeeming things.

I really couldn't care less whether a particular tribe-of-monkeys behavior has always been around or not. My ethical compass is pretty firmly tuned to one fundamental principle: the net increase in human freedom — freedom of action, and freedom from harm; freedom of expression, and freedom from exploitation. I care whether a particular tribe-of-monkeys behavior serves to benefit one group of monkeys at the expense of another.

To my mind, this one — the concentration of power in the hands of a few, built on the backs of many, which is then used to enact social norms or policy that are often counter to the interests of those many — does.

(Edited)

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by eurleif on Saturday March 09, 2013 @06:46PM (#5350031)
No one is forced to participate in a corporation. If you like freedom so much, why don't you think people should be free to choose to pool their resources, and to give some of their control of those resources up to the group's leadership?
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by crusso on Saturday March 09, 2013 @11:29PM (#5350704)
I explicitly stated that people choose to group together to concentrate power.

The examples given were to counter your specific argument against corporations by showing you that there are many similar organizations that are acceptable concentrations of power.

The rest of your post ignored that context and furiously battled a straw man.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by Evbn on Saturday March 09, 2013 @10:07PM (#5350532)
You changed the meaning of 'concentrate'. People don't intend to have their orgs hijacked by their leaders, and some groups have bylaws to prevent that.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by crusso on Saturday March 09, 2013 @11:20PM (#5350686)
And who is to decide the orgs that have the proper bylaws and restrictions and the orgs that don't?
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by snowwrestler on Saturday March 09, 2013 @12:03PM (#5348904)
The members of a corporation are the shareholders, not the employees. The employee equivalent to a corporation is a union, which also has free speech rights.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by rosser on Saturday March 09, 2013 @03:36PM (#5349545)
So what about employees who, for whatever reason, can't unionize? Do they simply forfeit the ability to avail themselves of collective speech?
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by snowwrestler on Saturday March 09, 2013 @05:55PM (#5349912)
Certainly not! I'm not in a union and I give money and time to a variety of nonprofit organizations. The EFF, for instance, is a corporation that exists to concentrate the power of many people who care about online rights and freedoms. The Sierra Club is a corporation that concentrates the power of people who care about the environment. Etc.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by Evbn on Saturday March 09, 2013 @10:09PM (#5350536)
You giving money to EFF has nothing to do with being a corporation. You are not a controlling member of the EFF.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by snowwrestler on Sunday March 10, 2013 @12:40AM (#5350886)
EFF is just an example. The point is that any group of individuals can form and/or fund a corporation to concentrate their speech on whatever topic they want.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by chc on Saturday March 09, 2013 @03:53AM (#5347875)
But you do lose many of your responsibilities behind the corporate veil. That's the thing that's so weird. Corporations don't merely give their constituent people a vehicle to exercise their rights. Corporations are totally separate people from any person inside the corporation.
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by crusso on Saturday March 09, 2013 @10:52AM (#5348665)
How does the corporate veil affect free speech?

Just looked at the largest union, the NEA. It's incorporated in many states for various reasons. Should that prevent it from participating in political discourse?

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by snowwrestler on Saturday March 09, 2013 @06:20PM (#5349980)
The corporate veil protects shareholders from being personally liable for the debts and obligations incurred by the corporation. Speech does not create debts or obligations, so the veil is not an issue.

Corporate speech is subject to some regulation, just like personal speech. Corporations can be sued for slander and libel, advertisements must meet certain standards of truthfulness, etc.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by Evbn on Saturday March 09, 2013 @10:10PM (#5350538)
If you commit libel, you are liable.

If your corporation commits libel, you are not liable.

That's one problem.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by crusso on Saturday March 09, 2013 @11:34PM (#5350710)
On top of the fact that it's practically impossible to make a libel accusation stick when political speech is even barely provable - being incorporated doesn't prevent a libel proceeding from moving forward. It just means that it's more difficult to pin it to individuals within the corporation.

Even then, there are ways that the corporate veil can be pierced to still go after individuals.

Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B... by snowwrestler on Sunday March 10, 2013 @12:26AM (#5350852)
Why is that a problem?