This negatively affected a lot of their customers in many ways (overspending on heroku, time wasted, lost customers and revenue).
When Heroku's customers have incurred significant costs and/or losses because of Heroku's false claims, I don't see why this is so inappropriate. We need to make companies accountable for their claims.
For context, I am a Heroku customer and have been significantly affected by all of this. I won't participate in the lawsuit but I can understand why others would.
As a long time Heroku user, I was pissed when I heard this...but they have done so much good for my own development career and freelance gigs, that this is easily forgiveable with a slap on the wrist and a partial refund to customers that have paid a lot over the years.
More than likely, they just never realized how big of a deal it was - because they were busy expanding. A few customers (few being relative to their total support requests) probably did inquire and some manager probably developed the response that they are aware of the problem, but not dealing with it right now.
It's not as if they built the company on the premise that they are going to say 1 thing and do something else.
This is just something that fell through the cracks as they grew.
Let's not blow it out of proportion.
EDIT: comma placement.
They have the resources to handle the suit and fix the "damn problems" at the same time.
Regardless, the point has been made. They need to compensate those customers - but this lawsuit is frivolous, opportunistic and going too far.
This is the right thing to do. Heroku made their bed and now they must lie in it.
Nice template for an emotional appeal you've got there, dawg (seriously, wtf are you going for with the vernacular embellishments)
Your argument justifies malfeasance without penalty for any entity. Swap out 'Heroku' for Monsanto, Microsoft, or banks that launder money for drug cartels and read it again. See if you still buy the reasoning. If misleading and lying to customers (your words) isn't enough for a lawsuit, what is?
(Not saying Heroku is equivalent to any of the above companies, just illustrating the lack of reason in parent post).
I think Heroku has done a tremendous amount of good, especially in the Ruby community. This needs to be considered with the bad.
I hope RapGenius is not the lead plaintiff in this, otherwise I will be very disappointed.
I applaud them for raising this issue, and doing all the research they did. We are all much better off for it.
I applaud them for sticking to their guns to make sure Heroku fixes the issue.
But if they join this class action suit, in my humble opinion, it is one step too far. What is the max they can realistically expect to get back from Heroku? $250K? $500K? Surely not the entire $20K/mo, so I doubt it will be that much.
Given all the money they have raised so far, if I were one of their investors I would start to ask questions about if they are wasting their time frivolously beating a dead horse.
This is getting into 'bad karma' territory. I am sure someone, at some point, will want to sue RapGenius....they may remember how they behave now.
So yes, keep up the pressure, and keep forcing Heroku to fix their faulty systems.
But a class action suit dawg? I think not.